Same happened to us. Go to valentine stables select buy horses, go to Ardennes and buy again. It should be free. It didn't show up automatically I had to buy Like first time but now it is back. I have to do this every time my horse goes missing and can only get it from the stables in valentine but at least I still have it
The "I've lost my horse" thread.
in Red Dead Redemption 2
Posted · Edited by Scooter
Same happened to us. Go to valentine stables select buy horses, go to Ardennes and buy again. It should be free. It didn't show up automatically I had to buy Like first time but now it is back. I have to do this every time my horse goes missing and can only get it from the stables in valentine but at least I still have it