LordCheese

Oh ok, thanks for that. What about the witness from black water who gives you the pen, is he a one off no repeat mission?

Hi, I was playing RDR2 and I have had 2 instances where i screwed up a chance mission, one was the snake bite man. I saved him and then he offered a free item from the gun store however the store was shut so I had to wait. I went back later to find the man gone and the deal non existant. Another Instance is a shooting bottle competition, I accidentily pistol whiped the another guy. Is there a way to redo these?