Leaderboard

What I do to break a horse is pull back on the left thumb stick and just wiggle it back and forth. And as soon as the horse is broken I call my other horse over and put my saddle on the new horse. That gives you bonding level one and the horse is now yours permanently. So in doing that, you can break and keep any and every horse in the game. Just remember to stable your horses if you already have 2 out and are wanting to break and keep another one. If you don't you'll lose one of your previously gotten horses. It's how I lost the red chestnut Arabian. Luckily I still had the white Arabian.