Definitely a bug. I know how the horse mechanics work. My thoroughbred was the preorder version, was stabled and I have the camp stable feature unlocked. I logged in somewhere in chapter three, whistled for my horse (white Arabian) and both my Arabian and some new horse bearing the same name as my thoroughbred showed up!! The new horse has absolute garbage stats (3/3) and doesn’t even come close to looking the same. The thoroughbred was stabled in Valentine, had not died and was not in a mission that caused me to use another horse. The game just....stole it. Thanx Rockstar. Way to take my $80 and leave me with yet one more item gone (this is NOT the first time the game has taken my things). About damn sick of it.
