Thanks Parzival. Wife and I are afraid of losing a years worth of game play, both of us lvl 170+. To double check, even a pre-owned disk would get me back in? I'd rather spend $20 for a used disk than another $100 for a new Ultimate disk. I noticed edge of this disk starting to delaminate, so it's when, not if.
Another lame question please. As long as I save our paid for game in Xbox, Xbox does not care which RDR2 disk, new, used, Standard or Ultimate is used to start the game with? I save game to Xbox console and just use disk to start the game.