*SPOILERS* I might be asking for too much From R*

[LargerBoxes]

Spoiler

I know there are lots of people complaining that the story is too long already but i found it a good length for the story! they did drag out some plots a little too long but it was overall amazing! i just wish they could've put in more say on some of the missions or more options in the game in general! i dislike the fact that they make you get so deep into the story with Arthur and then they just kill him off! i realize he isn't in Red Dead Redemption but it would have been cool if they could've taken a different approach and you could have just gotten around the sickness even though that's what makes Arthur see what life really has to offer and there's not so much of a point in being such a horrible man before he leaves the earth and either way they still could've made it so Arthur could live and not be in Red Dead Redemption like maybe he could've moved somewhere else and started a family away from everything and still kept in touch with John and his family or you could play as Arthur still! Also i kinda wish that they could've almost remastered Red Dead Redemption along with this so you could play it again with the same graphics and feel with the same story but it would be your choice to go through with basically playing Red Dead Redemption again because now playing as John it feel like the story is just left at a stand still even though you know how the story plays out it would be nice to be able to go through that story again without making myself suffer the graphics Could've even made it an add on with an extra edition for the people who would want it! 

 

Edited November 6, 2018 by LargerBoxes

[DylBandit]

2 hours ago, LargerBoxes said:

  Hide contents

I know there are lots of people complaining that the story is too long already but i found it a good length for the story! they did drag out some plots a little too long but it was overall amazing! i just wish they could've put in more say on some of the missions or more options in the game in general! i dislike the fact that they make you get so deep into the story with Arthur and then they just kill him off! i realize he isn't in Red Dead Redemption but it would have been cool if they could've taken a different approach and you could have just gotten around the sickness even though that's what makes Arthur see what life really has to offer and there's not so much of a point in being such a horrible man before he leaves the earth and either way they still could've made it so Arthur could live and not be in Red Dead Redemption like maybe he could've moved somewhere else and started a family away from everything and still kept in touch with John and his family or you could play as Arthur still! Also i kinda wish that they could've almost remastered Red Dead Redemption along with this so you could play it again with the same graphics and feel with the same story but it would be your choice to go through with basically playing Red Dead Redemption again because now playing as John it feel like the story is just left at a stand still even though you know how the story plays out it would be nice to be able to go through that story again without making myself suffer the graphics Could've even made it an add on with an extra edition for the people who would want it! 

  

Spoiler

Yeah, it's unfortunate Arthur had to go that way, but it makes sense. Arthur wasn't in the original Red Dead Redemption, so if he lived in this game, he would have gone back to John in the original game because he cared for John a lot.

 

 

[LargerBoxes]

2 hours ago, DylBandit said:

  Hide contents

Yeah, it's unfortunate Arthur had to go that way, but it makes sense. Arthur wasn't in the original Red Dead Redemption, so if he lived in this game, he would have gone back to John in the original game because he cared for John a lot.

 

 

Spoiler

 

Yeah fair point! Just feels weird now to kinda build an attachment in a way with Arthur to just have him die and then barely have any remorse or have his name only mentioned in a little part of the epilogue here and there but then again John, Charles and Sadie made it up a bit at the end of the epilogue!

 

 

Edited November 7, 2018 by LargerBoxes

[DylBandit]

@LargerBoxes

Spoiler

Yes, it was very hard to see Arthur go on such terms. I built a big connection playing him, and I was very upset when he passed. You can definitely recognize good story writing when you feel sad about a character.