Horse reappeared in other play through.

[Foundyalenny]

So this weird thing has happened multiple times on my second play through of RDR2. In my first play through i had one horse that i bought from the stables that i used for the entire game intill the start of the epilogue. In my second play through I've found random horses with the exact likeness of that same horse and even having the name i had given it. Their not bonded to me, their random ones. Anyone have any ideas why this happens? 

[bluntTR4P]

That is strange. They have the nicknames you gave them but they aren't yours? Maybe the game just saves the horses and when you create a new save file they just get duplicated. 

[mickeyC]

As Arthur I had the same Palamino all the way through the game after selling the first one I traded Hoseas old Shire horse for.

Spoiler

I revived him a couple of times during the game and had him right through to the Mount Hagen shoot out when the horse is mown down by gunfire. Arthur whispers thank you to the horse as he is dying...F***ing heart breaking. When I play as John I buy a $1200 dollar Arab and keep him all the way through.

 

Edited April 30, 2019 by Kean_1
hid spoiler