Stars of the Stage
- Laurence Dunn - Inside a house located to the North of Rhodes, Lemoyne. The house is right on the Southfield Flats on the map.
- Louis Durand - Next to a ruined house. The house can be found to the West of the Van Horn Trading Post.
- Jesse Raymond - Inside a house found to the north of Tumbleweed. The card itself is on a windowsill.
- Augusta Tremlow - On a windmill located to the north of Little Creek River, north of Strawberry. The mill is located to the north of the "Little" in Little Creek River on the map.
- Mabel Potter - Inside the theater in Saint Denis. The theater is located in the western part of the city. The actual card in on a table by the fireplace.
- Robin Koninsky - Inside the theater in Saint Denis. The card becomes available only after completing the mission "Fatherhood and Other Dreams" in Chapter 4. After the mission has been completed, all the performances must be viewed. Once this is done, the card will be found on a table beside the stage.
- Isadore Reid - On a wagon found in Valentine. The wagon is found to the west of the town.
- Irene Grubb - On a bench in the train station in New Autin, to the southwest of the Macfarlane's Ranch.
- Nettie Palmer - Inside the show tent in Valentine. The card is next to the projector.
- Jim Cobb - Inside a ruined out found on Lemoyne. The house is located east of the first "E" in Lemoyne on the map.
- Mittie Comstock - Near a house in New Hanover. The house can be found by going to the south of the "H" in New Hanover on the map.
- Robert Elliot Patchen - Next to a hut located close to Rhodes, Lemoyne. The hut is found by going to the south of Mattock Pond, which is located to the north of Rhodes.
Vistas of America
- New York - Outside a house in Caliga Hall, Lemoyne. The house is in the southern part of the town.
- Saint Denis - On a cart in Saint Denis. The cart is close to the train track in the southeastern part of the city.
- Blackwater - On top of the theater in Blackwater, West Elizabeth. The card is near the chimney on the roof.
- Armadillo - On a barrel in Armadillo, New Austin. The correct barrel is inside a pig pen to the west of town.
- Rio Bravo - On the windmill found at Flatneck Station, New Hanover
- The Grizzlies - Inside a shack found to the north of Lake Don Julio, to the south of Armadillo. The shack can be reached by following a side road near the lake.
- San Francisco - Inside a fort located to the west of Van Horn Trading Post. The card is inside the tower to the southeast of the fort
- Tall Trees - On a barrel found in the Flatneck Station, New Hanover. The right barrel is in the southern part of the station.
- Valentine - On a table inside the Valentine station. Very hard to miss.
- Chicago - On the windmill in Emerald Ranch, New Hanover. The windmill is to the south.
- Rhodes - In the graveyard of Rhodes, Lemoyne. The card itself is found on a grave.
- Annesburg - On a barrel in Annessburg. The barrel is close to the tracks for the minecart in the western part of the town.
The World's Champion
- Percy Wood - Near a well located in New Hanover. The well is found to the south of the "R" in New Hanover on the map.
- Edwin A Rowe - Inside a building found to the north of the "V" in Valentine. The building is across the Dakota River and past the train tracks.
- Theobald Getzin - Right outside a building found near Emerald Ranch, New Hanover. The right building is on the east side of the main road leading into the ranch.
- H.T. Slocum - On a box found inside a shack located close to the Bluewater Marsh, Lemoyne. The shack is right on the "H" in Marsh on the map.
- R.S. Harradon - Outside a house located in Bluewater Marsh, Lemoyne. The house can be found on the other side of the river where the shack with the H.T. Slocum card is found.
- E.D. Ewing - On a shelf found in the basement of a house in Lemoyne. The house is near Dewberry Creek, on the border with New Hanover. To reach the basement, search for a hatch in the middle of the house.
- Patsey Hill - In a house found in Saint Denis. The correct house is found to the north of the saloon and on the eastern side of the river.
- William Sleicher - On a table inside a house located in a small town close to the Heartlands Oil Fields, New Hanover. The house is in the southern part of the small town.
- Edwin Singerly - On the top of the tower found in the western part of Annesburg.
- Felix Hawley - On a table inside a cabin found close to Barrow Lagoon, Ambarino. It's the only cabin by the lagoon, hard to miss.
- Capt. Jack Page - Inside a small house found to the north of the "V" in Valentine on the map. The house is located in the Grizzles West region, and the house itself is near the train track.
- Axel McCormack - On a crate found in Saint Denis. The crate is found in the back of the saloon.