harry747

So IOW, if I don't sell the gold and other valuables, John will be better off. Good to know.

i have a question: when arthur dies, what does john get? nothing? arthur's money? his satchel and its contents? his horse? all of them?

Ok Then, I'll try that. Now I need a boat...

I guess they didn't go back because they had more important things to worry about. Like surviving.

Hi. I've caught most of the legendary fish, but I don't know how to catch the one on the island. Is it possible to catch that one before the epilogue? The thing is that the whole island is red, and I don't want them to shoot me.

Isn't that the dock at the camp? I usually pull out bass and trout there. Then again, i usually use lake lures, so cheese bait would probably yield different results.

That's where I caught the legendary bluegill, so I thought there would be more bluegill there. But the vast majority of the fish I caught were not bluegill.

We all know that pronghorn ranch doesn't exist before the epilogue. So why is there a sign pointing the way to pronghorn ranch in strawberry in chapter 3?

South if the Braithwaite area. I put some potent predator bait on the edge of the forest, then I kept an eye on that spot from outside the forest, and when the critter appeared, a shot from the Springfield rifle and some knife work took care of it 🙂

finally got my panther 🙂 turns out i did need another deer, but that was no problem, and now i have the biggest satchel 🙂

what's the best spot to catch bluegill? i've tried o'creagh's run, elysian pool and the spot where i caught the legendary bluegill. result: only 2 or 3 bluegill plus lots and lots of other fish. and yes, i used the cheese bait. also, should i let the bait sit there or reel it in?

that's right, i don't play online. why? because i refuse to let sony spy on me and what i do with my playstations.

So, is it possible to buy valerian root in RDR2?

You seem to think that I'm talking about real life but I'm talking about rdr2. And I didn't buy it, i found it.

I have a couple of bottles of valerian root. What happens when I use them? What's the effect? And is the effect permanent? Is it ok to use the bottles now or should I wait?

You mean if I stay close to the shore I may have better luck? Worth a try...

I bought the boat, and I wish I hadn't wasted all that money. I was hoping to get to the other side of flat iron lake or the lannahechee river or go fishing on flat iron lake. Both turned out to be flops 😞 So my advice is DON'T BOTHER.

Ok, but why can't I use the boat to go fishing on flat iron lake like in the new south mission? I tried, but when I select the fishing rod, nothing happens.

Ok, i got it working now. But it still is a big disappointment. I tried to get to the other side of flat iron lake, and suddenly the boat sank for no reason and Arthur drowned. Also, i tried to use it for fishing in the middle of the lake but that was a flop too. So why spend all that money on a boat? I wish I hadn't.

Huh, gotta try that next time. But then the question is, why isn't there a prompt that explains this (assuming it works) at least the first few times? Horses and boats are not exactly the same thing.

And that's exactly where it is. But when I go near it, no prompts show up

Can't blame ya. What good is an object that just sits there and refuses to be used? Bloody expensive piece of decoration, if you ask me

Yes, of course it's story mode. My ps4 is offline because I find Sony's privacy policy UNACCEPTABLE. And I'm in chapter 3.

I found one (or rather it found me) in that area too. Problem is, it was only a 2-star :-( so I'll have to try again. That panther is the only thing between me and the biggest satchel.

I still need a panther and a wolf. Any tips on where to go and how to hunt? I tried predator bait but all i got was a bunch of wild pigs 😞 I may need another deer too but I'll cross that bridge when I come to it...