You know, I've never actually noticed if I've gotten perfect honor prior to Chapter 6. I imagine it can be done. Throwing fish back, doing chores, and complimenting people actually awards a minuscule amount of honor, though. I had to do all three dozens of times each before noticing a difference in the meter. Then I usually end up doing something to toss it all away. I just hate those times when you accidentally shoot someone six times or blow their leg off with a shotgun, don't you? 😒
If you think about it, Chapter 2 is the best chapter in the game for two simple reasons:
*Dutch isn't nuts yet (I mean, aside from that time in camp when he randomly blurts out to Arthur that Arthur will betray him).
*Micah's in jail.
😄