C20Dragon

I've seen this brought up a bit on this forum. Players saying there is potential chance you will be attacking someone that is defending themselves. Well first off if a player shots at or kills you, the attacking player will have medium hostility towards you & only show up pink to you. In this case you have to right to kill him. If you kill the medium hostile player you will not appear pink or red to the rest of the players in the server. Now for those that shoot first or kill first. I have tested this too. As I mention once in another topic, I spawned in and was getting dynamite thrown at me. But the 3 players doing it, never hit me. I was able to get away to the closest shop. When the 3 players decide to go after another random that went into the saloon just down the street. Well I decide to act. Riding up to the 3 players & throwing dynamite at them killing 2 of the 3 players. I turned medium hostility & just rode away. As it looked like I was the aggressor. When you are medium hostility you only show up pink to the person you attacked and to everyone in the vicinity. I'm not sure how many time I had to kill them to get high hostility? I just rode away not caring about the situation anymore. Players with high hostility will show up as dark red blip on the map. they'll show up anywhere on the map & to everyone. I spawned in by Manteca Falls & was going to head to Thieves Landing. But I noticed a red blip & decided to check out the situation. By the time I got to him, he was in Tumbleweed & notice he was in a shoot out with 4 other players. So I looked up their ranks. The red / high hostile player was rank 80. The 4 players he was shooting at, they were all under the rank of 10. So I waited sitting on top of the cliff side, East of town looking down. The high hostile player killed the 4 players easy. when the 4 players spawned in 2 of the 4 rode West out of Tumbleweed. While the high hostile player killed the other two again. I'm still sitting on the cliff side. The high hostile player was in town and started to run East out of town on the main road right towards me. Happens to run right underneath me on the cliff. Well I decide to act & toss dynamite at him, killing the high hostile player. I didn't turn red. I waited for the high hostile player to spawn in and he started to go after me. I rode a little bit out of town away from the 4 low ranking player. Of course the high hostile player follows me, tries to shoot me & missed. I ended up killing him again. Well he spawns in and disappears. I look at the players list and he is no longer in the server. In my situation I believed that the rank 80 / high hostile player was picking on the 4 players under the rank of 10. Trying to get easy kills. Once he realized I wasn't an easy kill he left the server. It is easy to assess the situation before attacking. As long as you don't have the shoot 1st and ask question later mentality. In my experience players that are defending themselves don't go to the point that they get high hostility & appear red to everyone on the map. Most players that defend themselves try and leave the situation at some point. For those that get baited & kill 1st & continue to kill until you have high hostility. First off, you've kill the player / players countless of time to get to the level of high hostility & made no effort to defuse the situation and ride away. Just to let you know you will appear as a dark red blip to everyone in the server and everyone in the server can see where you are located. Doesn't matter if players are in Thieves Landing and your red dot is close to Tumbleweed. Just be prepared that others might intervene if you have high hostility. Blurred out the name to comply with the rules.

Old Man Jones map icon looks like this:

I think you should wait & get the express explosive rounds 1st. I use those more than incendiary buckshot. You will be able to get 10 rounds for each class of weapon. (Pistol, Revolver, Rifle, Repeater, & sniper rifle) compared to incendiary buckshot which is only for the shotgun. Plus explosive rounds you only need to find animal fat to craft the item, compared to Moonshine to craft the incendiary buckshot. Animal fat is easier to find (duck, goose, boar, or desert pig) compared to moonshine.

Sounds good, I notice the topic dropped quickly & don't want it to get buried under the other topics. I thought it would be best to combine it in the Animal & item location. Thank you.

You're welcome, glad it helps & happy everyone likes it. Any Moderator members can combine this topic with the RDR2 Animal & Item location request thread Only reason I made a new topic was, because I noticed only 10 member downloaded my v3 map in a few months. I didn't think many members knew about it or saw it. Compared to 20+ members downloaded the v4 map already in the past few days.

Thank you for clarifying. I was apologizing for using derogatory comments towards the player in my video.

The only reason I posted the video in this topic, was because the 1st post talks about players griefing / trolling or poaching said player. I just wanted to show members on this forum that it could even happen in a Fishing Challenge. A player griefing / trolling me by trying to prevent me from fishing & winning. I was hesitated to make this post due to the quote I used, my comments about the player & providing a video of proof. I didn't want to be a troll or griefer myself & wanted to follow the rules of the forum. So I blurred out the name. Hoping that it would comply with the rules. I thought Liquor's quote was a perfect representation of what that person was doing to me and to the member in the 1st post. Sorry, I won't do it again. If there is a next time, I'll just post the video without any derogatory comments.

Speaking of little pricks... I was in a Fishing Challenge. I understand if your winning, players will come by you and try and fish. But when the players stood right in front of me & tried to prevent me from fishing, I was surprised. But I guess I shouldn't be. I just kept on fishing. lol I blurred the name out to comply with the no name and shame rule.

I bought a new horse instead of a controller, I don’t seem to have this problem with the new one. Strange it does it with my two other horses. Thanks for the info everyone.

I agree, just shoot'em, grab your stuff and ride away. As I notice the other day you will only be Medium hostility for 2 mins. Then you can re-activate def mode & go sell your stuff or do whatever.

Hope it works for you, when you print. As I don’t have a printer and can’t test it that way. I know it works on a tablet & pc which you can zoom in onto the locations of interest for better clarity. I can’t test it on a phone as my phone is ancient. I hope however you try to use it works for you.

Do you have this mission completed in your story mission menu? Press start / Progression / Story Mission - here it will tell you what story missions you have done. If you do have it unlock / complete, you have to be positive honor to start it. If you are dishonorable, you can't start it from this menu and only can access it the quick join.

Hey all, I've updated my Map of the Land. Like to thank Moosh89 for helping with this update. I created a Hi-Res JPEG image file this time. So it's a 8mb file, compare to the others versions that were 2-3mb. If anyone is having trouble downloading this map, I can create a lower res file. Download Updated v4 Map Here: http://www.mediafire.com/view/o72ii82nb8or99k/Red_Dead_Online_Map_V5.jpg Dragon's Updated v4: - Remove some fishing locations. I didn't see fish spawning. - Found items in Plainview area. - Added Rescue Someone for Daily - Added Escort Someone for Daily - Added more animals for Daily - Found items in Camps S/W of Blackwater - Found more Gang Hideouts & Ambushes. - Found item in the Docks, Left of the Braithwaite Manor - Found bunch of items in Houses West of Whinyard Strait & Granite Pass - Found items by Shack, North of Y in Lemoyne / Moonshine x 2 - Added Camp Ambushes - Found items in House West of Deadboot Creek & Spider Gorge - Found items in abandon camp Under R in Heartland - Found items in abandon camp South of the U in New Austin. This isn't a complete map. This is just what I've found, Moosh89 found or what others have mentioned on this forum. Hope this helps, Enjoy!!!

I ran into this situation with griefers, I spawn into Saint Denis & right away notice 3 player West of me. I ran to the closest house to take cover & activate Def mode. At this point I hear dynamite blowing up all around me. I don't get hit, I jump a few fences to get away from the players & get on my horse and ride away. I see on my app they are following me and I hear more dynamite going off right behind me, but they don't hit me. So non of them turn red for me. I head to the nearest shop, which was the barber. Inside I notice the 3 players waiting for me outside. I look & of course they are in the same posse. I wait a bit and notice on my app there is another random player appear & goes into the saloon down the street. I see the 3 player leave me & head for the saloon. I've never done this before so I wanted to see what would happen. I'm still in def mode, so I ride up to the 3 griefers just outside of the saloon. 3 griefers are shooting in at the one player inside, as the one player shoots back. They don't notice me, so I throw a stick of dynamite & kill 2 of the 3 griefers. Right away I'm put into Medium hostility. So I just take off North out of the city. The 1 griefer that was left alive tries to follow me, by the time his horse gets to him. I'm long gone & no longer see them on the app. I start my timer on my phone to see how long I will stay in Medium hostility. It only took 2 mins for me to be able to activate Def mode again. In my opinion it should take a lot longer than 2 mins for me to go back to Def mode. Since technically it looked like I was the aggressor. I thought I read somewhere on R*, that if you attack someone in Def mode yours suppose to have increase hostility. I thought I would have high hostility instead of medium hostility and didn't think it would only be two mins to go back to Def mode. I'm not proud of myself for attacking players in Def mode, but they did start it.

Thanks for the reply. I never thought my controller would be the issue. Might have to get a new one because that is annoying.

No one has this problem with their horse?🙁 I can post a video if you don’t understand what I’m talking about?

I've been having the same issue for a couple of weeks now. Can't setup a camp. I have to reform my persistent posse and setup a camp that way. Sometimes it works sometimes it doesn't. If you don't have a persistent posse, try and create a temp one and see if that works for you.

I have the Missouri Fox Trotter & Arabian... The issue I'm having with these two horses. The horse & I will be facing the bot, when I go to aim at a bot the horse will turn 180 degrees facing away from the bot. This is annoying, every time I try to shoot a bot the horse turns and want to face the opposite direction. Like it wants to run away from the fight. As if the horse is telling me lets get the heck out of here. My question is to you all, do all the horse do this? Does yours? Before I waste money buying a 3rd horse (War horse) to see if this solve my problem. I'm curious if all horse do this. If I recall this wasn't an issue in story, This is only a problem with online. Thanks for any info you all my provide.

They are located in the in the Bluewater Marsh area. North of Saint Denis

If you have two of the same carcasses on the sides of your horse. As Moosh has 2 perfect turkey carcasses, it will only show up as one icon now, when you try to sell it. If you watch the video again one turkey sells for 1.00, but when Moosh click the one turkey icon to be sold. Moosh gets $2.00 & it shows 2 x perfect turkey carcass sold in the info to the right. So even though there is only one icon to be sold, you will still get credit for both when you sell the one icon.

You realize if R* adds private lobbies, you probably won't be able to do Strange mission / Escort / Rescue & so on. Just like they did in GTAO, where you can't do CEO & other mission. Plus I don't think R* will create private lobbies. when I am in the same lobby for hours hunting and I notice the server has less then 5 players. (When I first join it had 20+) I get disconnected / some error & get put back into lobby with 20+ players. Not sure, but I'm thinking R* doesn't want players to be by themselves in lobbies. When I join a region off the main menu or play a mission & afterwards get placed in a new server. I'm always spawning in with players all around me. I just fast travel to the opposite side of the map & I won't see anyone around. This doesn't work all the time, but if I want to hunt in Saint Denis. I will spawn in New Austin and make my way over to Rhodes or Saint Denis. Most times no one is there or only a few. Compared to the other side which is a war zone, because I spawned in over there.

Unfortunately the Public Enemy was last weeks featured Showdown (Reason why it show up on the Main menu). This week is Sport of Kings. Only way to play Public Enemy now, is if you are lucky enough to get it when you join a random Showdown Series.

HI all, I never looking in the off topic section until now and saw the introduce yourself. I've been playing Red Dead 2 since it came out and be playing online since day one of the beta. I'm a rank 180 on Xbox. I mainly do daily's, hunting, fishing, story missions & all the other activative in free roam. I don't care for strange mission as most of them to me, feel like I'm a delivery boy. Take this wagon over here and take it back over there. lol I will go play Paperboy on Nintendo if I want to do errands. I only do them when friends ask me to help out. I keep to myself ,but if a griefer bother me and shoot at me. I don't care if he's rank 6. I got 50 explosive rounds for him. Especially in a game that a 6 year old can kill you easy with auto-aim. The whole point is not to die. But I have no problems trolling a griefer that shoots at me. I'll hunt him down until he quits the game or I get bored. With all the cancer players in this game. I try to show other players that there are some good players here. So if I see a low ranking players hunting or at the butcher shop. I will give you my 3 star cougar or whatever I have. As I know the struggles with making money when you're a low rank. take it easy you all.

In order for it to take effect you will have to fast travel / join a mission / have some kind of loadscreen. After you fast travel you will see your heart icon display an arrow up for gaining weight or an arrow down for losing weight (If you don't eat for a few in-game days). So if you eat 10 meat and stay in a server for an hour without fast traveling you will not see any difference. So just eat 10 meats and fast travel you should see a difference in your stats. If you don't notice anything after fast traveling, you might have a glitch.

If that is something new, cool. Because I've been thinking once the Trader / Bounty Hunter / Collector update comes out this Summer. I was think the Traders will be able to hunt and collect x number amount of large animals and be able to sell them at your camp. Instead of riding to a butcher to sell. Just a thought I've had. If that is something new players are seeing, maybe the Summer update isn't that far away. I'm on Xbox & I haven't seen that before, but I don't spend much time at my camp. lumper, what camp theme do you use? I will buy it and see if I can see it on xbox. Edit: I found the R* newletter that mentions selling or build a business at camp as a trader. https://www.rockstargames.com/newswire/article/60954/Red-Dead-Online-World-Updates-New-Missions-Poker-and-The-Road-Ahead