The Blackangel

Have you been buying items from the trapper? A lot of his items either come in sets, or randomly. There's also the possibility that it was just an item you found by pure chance, since it's calling them weathered. Or looted off a body. The possibilities are practically endless. RDR2 does some weird things at times. What I would suggest is that you go to your compendium and check them out. The information on it may shed some light on them. I have yet to receive anything like that. So it's possible that you picked it up around X% and just forgot. Happens to me all the time.

That's what I was thinking. But just like @thepoodlescore, I've never seen a name on it either.

The Robard farm? Is this a Red Dead Online thing? I've never even heard of it.

I don’t know what the deal is, but I can never get the block out of the basement of this place. I loot everything else, but getting that block out of the wall is all but impossible. I have been lucky enough to get it in the past, but I don’t know what (if anything special) happened in the game that let me finally get it. Do I have to complete some specific mission? Is it a stranger mission? Is it permanently lost after a certain point? This drives me nuts every time I play the game.

Ave

Is sounds like an issue on your end. I have no issues of missing gore or inability to burn bodies. I can still take a shot gun and make a head completely explode by a direct shot at it. You may be dealing with a bigger glitch than normal. It might be able to be fixed by reinstalling the game if it's something that hinders your gameplay. But if it's just a curiosity, or it only irks you, then I wouldn't really worry about it all that much.

The most annoying thing is when you're in town and try to mount up on your horse, but accidentally mount a horse that isn't yours. You lose honor and end up with the sheriff after you. It's the reason I ride the white Arabian. I'm colorblind, and easily mistake other horses for mine. Especially at night. And since the only white horses I've ever seen are either The Count or Shire horses, it's easy for me to distinguish mine. And to make sure I can tell mine from The Count in camp, I always color her tail black. You're dead on that chapter 2 is the best. The camp is still tight as blood, Micah's not around, and you can get things done that you want to focus on. Like getting the Legend Of The East satchel, collecting items to make money (gold bars for instance) or trying to find your preferred horse breed. Typically that means breaking and bonding with a wild horse. Another question about honor comes to mind. Have you ever gotten honor dinged just for riding into camp? Or is that just some jackass sh*t that happens to me for some unknown reason?

I didn't really think it through. I just thought I needed to mention it to explain how I knew. Too often people require proof of whether or not you "know" something, so at this point, it's more or less instinct.

As I said in my first post, I've gotten the fluorite and ammolite several times. In my opinion they're easy to get. I know there's a difference between transgender and drag. I'm transgender.😉

Has anyone else been dinged on their honor just for riding into camp? This happens to me all the damn time. I'm at a loss of what to make of it other than to call it annoying.

You mentioned a few that I had forgotten. I've collected the two meteorite pieces, viking comb, cat skull mask, Pagan burial mask, and the Native American ring. Then there's the random knives and axes. I've also gotten the owl feather trinket from Rains Fall after getting the chanupa back for him. There's Catherine Braithwaite's broach that you can get off her corpse. I'm sure everyone has gotten it, but there's also the emerald you get from "Margaret" after returning his animals to him. Transgender is fine, but he's just a guy in a dress. I was about to say gold ingot, but there remembered that so far I have come up with 2. Everything else was a bar of gold. I've also found the stuff needed for crafting like the petrified wood, and the shell fragment. As for the female fertility statue, I've never seen it respawn. When I look at it, it says it's a unique item. And with the other fertility statue, isn't it in New Austin? If so, then only way for me to get it is either in the epilogue, or to exploit a glitch to go down there. With Penelope and Beau, she always offers a sapphire bracelet. Personally, I turn it down. I'll have to check my game, but that's all I can think of at the moment. **************************************************************** While we're on the subject I want to see who has found some of these spots. Face In The Mountain Statue Puzzle

Is it possible to get perfect honor prior to chapter 6? I’ve never seen it happen, but at the same time see no reason why it couldn’t happen. Unless the scripters wrote the game that way. I personally like to keep the game in chapter 2 and/or 3 for a lot of reasons. So I’m curious if trying for it would be wasted effort. I keep my honor as high as I can get it, but can’t seem to get it past a certain point, no matter how many good deeds I do, or how many times I do chores around camp and donate to the box. Or how many fish I throw back.

What uniques has everyone found? I'm looking to find as many as possible. I'm playing the Ultimate Edition, so some of these may be unique to that. So far I have found: Gold Shield Female Fertility Statue Fluorite Ammolite Jimmy Brooks' Pen I'm not counting damp requests like the pipe for Dutch, mirror for Molly, or pen for Mary-Beth. I'm also not counting things that can be bought like the high roller revolver. That said, I've also picked up a few axes, tomahawks, and knives. But I'm not sure if they should be counted or not.

Are you playing on console or PC? That could present an issue. If you're on PC, have you run a virus check? Have you defragged it lately? Have you cleared out the cache any time recent? All those things could be an issue affecting the game. If you're on a console, the system memory could be full. You might need to delete a game or two. There's a trick to clean up your PS4 if that's what you're using.

It sounds like a massive glitch. RDR2 is full of glitches. You may need to reinstall the game. From what I understand, the PC version is worse for glitches than the console version.One of your rifles could have been put in your weapon locker for some reason. You could check that. As for getting new missions, look over the entire map and see if you find a yellow marker with a letter in it. Something like this image here.

I've never seen Guardians Of The Galaxy. But going by the picture, he looks like he belongs in LOTR Two Towers. He would fit right in with the Ent's.

What's groot?

The northernmost legendary animals I can think of are the moose, wolf, and grizzly. Or if you go all the way to the west side of the map, the bison.

From what I have seen in their stats, the white Arabian is the best one. The red chestnut and warped brindle are amazing horses also, but the white Arabian is so far the highest quality horse.

It puts an X over the fish on the map. They're also in your compendium.

Ok I hunted him down an killed the vampire. I specifically remember picking up his dagger and saving immediately. I have the bat wings, stringy meat, and drawing of him dead in my journal. But no dagger. I tried checking my weapons locker as well, but no dagger. I also have the army knife as well. But I can't find it either. I've searched all over my saddle, in everything I can find. But they just aren't showing up. The broken pirate sword is on my saddle, as well as the 2 bit hatchet. But neither of these knives are anywhere to be found. What am I missing?

I have to tell you, that one was a job for me to find. The cat eye was fairly simple. The only challenge there was finding the correct island. Considering that there so few islands, and that I was already fully familiar with biggest of them, it was easy enough. But actually finding that campsite with the hawk talon was a bitch.

I think I worded my statement wrong. I mean that I didn't know what items (specifically) were in the ultimate/special editions of the game that weren't in the regular copy. After having played the ultimate edition, I honestly don't think I could play the regular one. I'm spoiled. It's the same way in Diablo II. I couldn't play it without the expansion pack either. I'm a nerd.

I didn't know those guns were addons in the game. I've only played the special/ultimate editions of the game, so I'm sure I missed a lot from the regular edition. But it's cool to know exactly what addons the special/ultimate editions had.

I stumbled on this a few weeks ago, and had no knowledge of it until I found it. My question is simple though. Is this a special/ultimate edition exclusive? The same way the iguana scale and eagle talon trinkets are? I've found several things that I never would have thought of, purely by accident. Fluorite, ammolite, and female fertility statue just to name a few. I have the Ultimate edition of the game, despite me not being an online gamer. So I'm just really curious if ti's an exclusive or not.