Why is no big online gaming magazine talking about the graphical issues

[MN32410 Red_&_Dead]

For me it is really strange, that no big online magazine is talking about the graphical issues. This game has one of the highest review overall scores of all time. . IGN is now the first gaming magazine that talks about the HDR problem, but this is not the only problem to a lot of users especially the ps4 pro users.

WE need a petitition to confirm rockstar games with this unacceptable situation. Has Rockstar payed for the highscore reviews in the big online magazines. I have never saw a game that comes with those graphical issues on the market. I mean on consoles. All reviews that I saw are talking from the higher resolution of the XBox ONe X, and the checkerboarding of the PS4 Pro, but no magazine is analyzing the headache blur. All magazines say, best experience is on one x and than on pro. XBox ONe is the blurrriest version, because of the really low resolution.

 

We need a portal where we can do that.

 

Change.org?

Edited November 2, 2018 by MN32410 Red_&_Dead

[Poggy]

I admit that I find so many 10/10 scores a little confusing for this game.  It's a truly great game, but across the board 10/10??  Not convinced.

[MN32410 Red_&_Dead]

1 minute ago, Poggy said:

I admit that I find so many 10/10 scores a little confusing for this game.  It's a truly great game, but across the board 10/10??  Not convinced.

It was the same on GTA V. I´m not a big fan of this game. Trevor was to crazy for me. Control was not good for me. Real buggy on PC, but highest scores. I think I will say good buy to rockstar. AC Odyssey is a technical masterpeece on the Pro. No game has this detail. The scores are much lower. 

[BropolloCreed79]

1 hour ago, MN32410 Red_&_Dead said:

I´m not a big fan of this game

So... you came to a forum for the game?

1 hour ago, Poggy said:

It's a truly great game, but across the board 10/10??  Not convinced.

It's laughable that they can grade an incomplete game when the online mode hasn't even been released.  Are they only grading the story mode?  Fine, but the game is riddled with bugs and errors.  I can't tell you how many times I've had to shoot someone or choke them to death in a fistfight after ten minutes of beating the crap out of them because they won't go down.

 

[Melting Snowflakes]

Because all the articles in those magazines are written by millennial women who don't care, and know anything about the game, because they couldn't do anything else with their journalism degrees ...

(I'm feeling mean spirited today)

[Jahchurch]

5 hours ago, MN32410 Red_&_Dead said:

It was the same on GTA V. I´m not a big fan of this game. Trevor was to crazy for me. Control was not good for me. Real buggy on PC, but highest scores. I think I will say good buy to rockstar. AC Odyssey is a technical masterpeece on the Pro. No game has this detail. The scores are much lower. 

ACodyssey, as much as I enjoyed it, is a buggy mess. It got lower scores because it's a 40 hour game spread across 60 hours due to fillers and repetitive activities. Red Dead has a much higher development value. I have not run into any bugs with the game compared to the countless in AC: Odyssey. In Odyssey they couldn't even get the live events working, and even when I managed to get the epic ship quest, it was removed from my quest log before I could even finish it locking me out of it completely. Plus the whole time I was playing it, after update 1.03 the merc system was bugged to the point that it didn't even work during my whole time of beating the campaign. On top of that it was poorly optimized, especially on PC. Origins I was able to run the game at 4k 30fps, where I could not do the same for Odyssey even though it was on the same engine. Try pulling a torch out while in a cave and watch your frames drop by 20 points. It was just a buggy mess overall.

RDR2 on the other hand, though not perfect, has been a much smoother experience, better fleshed out with more variety and more systems. The graphics trump Odyssey and run at a much smoother frame rate. Now unfortunately  because of the eye candy that it is, the base systems do struggle a lot more, but that would be a given because of the sub pare hardware that it has to run on. Xbox One has never been 1080p and always ran games at 900p or less. It's a given that the game struggles the most on that system. The time and quality of this game deserves a perfect score, because no game can be 100% perfect and bug free, but the amount of time this game was given, and quality that has been put into it, including the 500k plus lines of dialog and everything this games offers is why this game is scored so high compared to something like Odyssey that wasn't given the same amount of time and quality.

Edited November 2, 2018 by Jahchurch

[MN32410 Red_&_Dead]

On PC it is real buggy. Crashing a lot of times if you are online in uplay. On PS4 Pro. I have no crashes no bugs. Mercenary bug seemed to be fixed right now. I think the overall graphic is a lot improved compared to origins on consoles, not really on PC.

 

Yes the mission design is way better in RDR2, but on pS4 Pro I have a lot of technical issues. Mission that I have absolved are not saved, and i can begin again and again. FRamerate stutters after an hour of playing. Cutcenes looking washed out. Textures are on low resolution. Yeah and the blurry mess. Control is not working really smooth in weapon gunplay. I think it would be the best Game since san andreas. I really love that game in the past.