Jump to content

Cast Your Live-Action RDR2 Actors/Actresses


dropkickennedy
 Share

Recommended Posts

I've been thinking through this, and though you could never capture the magic of RDR in a movie (maybe a series, but even then I don't know), I think it would be fun to cast actors you think could portray the characters on the big screen. If you had no budget, who would you cast?

Arthur Morgan - I was thinking Thomas Haden Church, but I believe he's a bit too old now. Maybe Josh Brolin?

John Marston - Norman Reedus 

Dutch van der Linde - Jeffrey Dean Morgan

Abigail Roberts - Odeya Rush

Bill Williamson - Vincent D'Onofrio

Charles Smith - Tough one. Can't find someone I like...

Colm O'Driscoll - Michael Shannon

Hosea Matthews - Richard Jenkins

Jack Marston - Don't really care haha

Javier Escuella - Diego Luna 

Josiah Trelawny - Sam Rockwell

Karen Jones - Christina Hendricks 

Kieran Duffy - Caleb Landry Jones

Lenny Summers - Daniel Kaluuya

Leopold Strauss - Martin Short

Mary-Beth Gaskill - Anya Taylor-Joy

Micah Bell - Steven Ogg (I honestly thought he was the voice actor until I looked him up)

Molly O'Shea - Orla Brady 

Orville Swanson - Kevin Bacon

Sadie Adler - Hard to top the voice actor as I would cast her but my other two options are Julia Garner or Emma Stone

Sean McGuire - Domhnall Gleeson

Simon Pearson - Dan Aykroyd

Susan Grimshaw - Helen Mirren

Tilly Jackson - Ruth Negga

Uncle - Jeff Bridges hahaha. Maybe Stellan Skarsgård

Edited by dropkickennedy
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, dropkickennedy said:

I've been thinking through this, and though you could never capture the magic of RDR in a movie (maybe a series, but even then I don't know), I think it would be fun to cast actors you think could portray the characters on the big screen. If you had no budget, who would you cast?

Arthur Morgan - I was thinking Thomas Haden Church, but I believe he's a bit too old now. Maybe Josh Brolin?

John Marston - Norman Reedus 

Dutch van der Linde - Jeffrey Dean Morgan

Abigail Roberts - Odeya Rush

Bill Williamson - Vincent D'Onofrio

Charles Smith - Tough one. Can't find someone I like...

Colm O'Driscoll - Michael Shannon

Hosea Matthews - Richard Jenkins

Jack Marston - Don't really care haha

Javier Escuella - Diego Luna 

Josiah Trelawny - Sam Rockwell

Karen Jones - Christina Hendricks 

Kieran Duffy - Caleb Landry Jones

Lenny Summers - Daniel Kaluuya

Leopold Strauss - Martin Short

Mary-Beth Gaskill - Anya Taylor-Joy

Micah Bell - Steven Ogg (I honestly thought he was the voice actor until I looked him up)

Molly O'Shea - Orla Brady 

Orville Swanson - Kevin Bacon

Sadie Adler - Hard to top the voice actor as I would cast her but my other two options are Julia Garner or Emma Stone

Sean McGuire - Domhnall Gleeson

Simon Pearson - Dan Aykroyd

Susan Grimshaw - Helen Mirren

Tilly Jackson - Ruth Negga

Uncle - Jeff Bridges hahaha. Maybe Stellan Skarsgård

Good choices, I'd just change a few - 

Micah = Dennis Haysbert  -  i can't stand him and i can't stand Micah, so perfect fit lol.

Abigail = Alexandra Daddario 

Mary-Beth = MIlana Vayntrub 

Kieran = Jeffrey Donovan 

Sadie = Gabrielle Anwar

Lenny = Trevor Jackson

TIlly = Paige Hurd

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Kormath said:

Good choices, I'd just change a few - 

Micah = Dennis Haysbert  -  i can't stand him and i can't stand Micah, so perfect fit lol.

Abigail = Alexandra Daddario 

Mary-Beth = MIlana Vayntrub 

Kieran = Jeffrey Donovan 

Sadie = Gabrielle Anwar

Lenny = Trevor Jackson

TIlly = Paige Hurd

What's in your wallet? you can't be talking about him right lmao🤣

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, sLLiMM said:

What's in your wallet? you can't be talking about him right lmao🤣

Are you referring to Dennis Haysbert?  He's the one that does the Allstate insurance commercials, he's plays the phone or whatever is causing the wreck/damage.

Capital One credit cards are the What's in your Wallet ones.  that's been Samuel L Jackson and Jennifer Garner for the last what decade maybe?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Kormath said:

Gerard Butler might make a good Arthur also.  And what about Hugh Jackman for Dutch?

I can dig Hugh as Dutch. We really haven't seen him play a "bad guy" yet. I would be interested to see that.

I could see Butler as Arthur. I just think his accent always pokes through haha

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 6 months later...
12 hours ago, buttlint said:

Dutch = Liam Neeson

He certainly has the chops for long winded monologues.

 

liamneeson.jpg

yeah but Liam's a badass.  Total opposite of Dutch. 

Dutch is a poser, a con man, Alec Baldwin comes to mind right off for him.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Kormath said:

yeah but Liam's a badass.  Total opposite of Dutch. 

Dutch is a poser, a con man, Alec Baldwin comes to mind right off for him.

If we're going to typecast............... (the guy on the right)

 

segal.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

LATEST RDR2 NEWS CLIPS

×
×
  • Create New...