How high are your expectations?

[shawn]

If we were to give an estimation of how well we think the game will do overall and for our own personal tastes...

What would you say you rank RDR2 on a 1 to 10 scale for overall game factors as well as your own personal score?

I think the game will be about a 8.2/10 overall. This is in terms of story, game-play, online, sales, graphics, and everything in between. My own personal score I am expecting it to be a 9.5 or higher just because the first one got about that from me. I can't see it being below an 8 for an overall rating. 

[ChrisCr0ss]

I am not sure what I will give it. I could say a 10 right now but it wouldn't be based on anything other than the trailer which didn't tell us much of anything. I think I can agree about the game overall being at least an 8 seeing as the last one got 9.5 at Gamespot.

[UKSammy84]

You mean like review it in advance... pretty hard to do

[elmZ]

On 5/9/2017 at 7:48 PM, UKSammy84 said:

You mean like review it in advance... pretty hard to do

I think this is in terms of guessing what it will be based on the old one but still, I can't grade my expectations I can just say they are pretty high up there. 

[redscrew]

On 5/9/2017 at 6:22 PM, ChrisCr0ss said:

I am not sure what I will give it. I could say a 10 right now but it wouldn't be based on anything other than the trailer which didn't tell us much of anything. I think I can agree about the game overall being at least an 8 seeing as the last one got 9.5 at Gamespot.

This. 

I don't want to aim too high or anything without knowing more on the game but I think this is a safe bet. 

[DarkShark]

I'm not sure. I am expecting a 10/10 game but I always keep my expectations in life pretty high. 

Hence me ending up getting disappointed a lot.. lol

[GatoNegro]

10/10

10/10

Tens across the board from me and from the gaming experts. There is not way they will allow another game to outshine them and I am firm in saying this will be better than GTA V as well. 

[CowBoii]

On 5/15/2017 at 7:55 PM, GatoNegro said:

10/10

10/10

Tens across the board from me and from the gaming experts. There is not way they will allow another game to outshine them and I am firm in saying this will be better than GTA V as well. 

I would not go as far to say it will out rank GTA V just because the GTA games have a much bigger fan base but I can see the game getting great ratings and scores across the board. I would be more shocked to see it tank than actually do good.