Benjo

Yeah this has been discussed before and the consensus is that it's not Abigail. Doesn't look anything like her.

Not sure. Looking through the trailers it's true I can't see anyone else with one of these satchels, and sometimes Arthur has one, sometimes he doesn't. That looks like a lot like an assumption - do you have a source for that? Has it been mentioned in an interview or something? I'm not suggesting JM won't be playable, in fact I've long assumed he would be, but this seems like a bit of a stretch as a pointer that he is.

Start with the worst case and everything other than that is better.

Another delay.

Why couldn't you use passive mode?

It would be bad if your horse died but by golly imagine if your F-ing dog died

No I don't think so, I mentioned it in case you wanted to check it out. I doubt R$ would base anything they do on any other games tbh, they're too big for that.

This is pretty much in FC5, not sure if you've played it.

My guess would be that they would be invited to your camp, not inside your tent.

Exactly like Far Cry though. I'm not saying it would be anything but a great addition but it's a bit too close to that franchise for me.

Would work for offline definitely, and I wouldn't mind it being in the game. Wouldn't work for online of course as it's realtime.

Airplane food.

The format of most American TV shows. Open with 5 minutes of recap from last show. Then 5 minutes of spoilers for this show. Then 5 minutes of actual footage. 5 minute commercial break 5 minutes of recap 5 minutes of spoilers 5 minutes of footage 5 minute commerical break 5 minutes of recap 10 minutes of footage. 5 minutes of "next week on..."

Never knew that - this is true?

Yeah personally I like that from an immersion point of view. Could get annoying when you're working through the missions though. If they did introduce it they would have to perhaps have it as an option to switch on / off, but I can't see that happening.

No we already know there are a lot more dynamics to hunting.

Not a bad theory! Interesting the stuff about the train robbery etc.

Well, if I won I would donate it to the local orphanage. Wouldn't you? ????

Just any gang with the name 'boys' in. I feel our gangs that murder and pillage shouldn't discrimiate against gender. How about "The Billiard non-gender-specific-people-who-are-free-to-identify-as-any-or-no-gender-at-all"? Kinda rolls off the tongue.

Are girls not allowed?

It's actually more like $600 - 1000.

I think this might be Yoda's point. The fact you have to watch YT tutorials on how to workaround the system to avoid griefers is the problem.

Am I the only person who has never played that? I 100%ed RDR but have just never been interested in the zombie stuff, and definitely not interested enough to pay money for it.

I'm not really following this. Surely owning a PS4 would make you buy the PS4 version whether it was cross-platform or not? It's online play only that they are talking about here, so PS4 players can be in the same lobbies as XBox players. The way I'm reading your post is that you are talking about the potential of buying a physical XBox game to play on your PS4, which of course would never be the case. Am I reading it wrong?