My 2 biggest complaints.

[Cliffs]

10 hours ago, Harley clark said:

Yea the sh*t talking is pretty bad.. I had a guy ride up to me the run off and was waiting for me up the trail a bit so I had my pump out in case he was gonna try anything then as I was approaching he said “you ain’t sh*t bro whatcha gonna do?” I didn’t even respond But before he was even able to get a gun out I got a headshot on him and killed him so yea I really ain’t sh*t 😂

And then he went on a forum somewhere and complained about this arsehat named H...C... that shot him because he shot him before....do you see how that works?

[Cliffs]

14 hours ago, Harley clark said:

Oh and go on the defense and kill them first? Hmmm wow I would’ve never thought of that! What a great idea cuz you can totally kill 3 guys and get to the mission start point before they respawn and come back! Wow I must be an idiot for not thinking of that before! Why don’t you try it and come back and tell me how it works out for you. Id bet money you get 2 of 3 down and then those will have respawned by time you get the 3rd down then your in the same predicament that you were before you started. And MAYBE I’m bored with single player. I have a million dollars and nothing else to buy or unlock so I’m sorry I enjoy the idea of creating a character and actually having sh*t to work for and unlock now! But hey guys I guess all of us that are like me and hate trolls have to stop playing cuz this dudes obviously from R* and has all the answers and he says not to play the game anymore if we don’t like the idiots that aren’t even playing right. 

There are 3 of them and one of you....guess you have to man up and join/make your own posse. This afterall an MP game not single player.

 

I get the biatching about all the players running around killing everyone, that happens in every MP game and the biatching by you and me and others about is never going to chnage.

[Harley clark]

On 12/1/2018 at 6:11 AM, Cliffs said:

There are 3 of them and one of you....guess you have to man up and join/make your own posse. This afterall an MP game not single player.

 

I get the biatching about all the players running around killing everyone, that happens in every MP game and the biatching by you and me and others about is never going to chnage.

Man up and make a posse? Lol I have a posse. We have full time jobs not like all of us can be on all the time. I know us bitching ain’t gonna change it. Just venting bro

[Harley clark]

On 12/1/2018 at 6:09 AM, Cliffs said:

And then he went on a forum somewhere and complained about this arsehat named H...C... that shot him because he shot him before....do you see how that works?

Defending myself and running around killing everyone senselessly are 2 different things 

[Cliffs]

I hear ya Harley, so as not to start a forum feud with you, I want to be able to play like you also but alas, it is online MP.

[YodaMan 3D]

3 hours ago, Cliffs said:

I hear ya Harley, so as not to start a forum feud with you, I want to be able to play like you also but alas, it is online MP.

So then you understand that PvP players and PvE players can co-exist as long as both sides watch what they are doing.  For example I see a player hunting or shopping or fishing.  I will go out on a limb a say those people don't want to PvP.  Now if I see a group of players running around shooting everyone and everything, then I am pretty sure they want to PvP.  

Now from what I read from you.  You think they are there, they want to PvP with me regardless of whatever they seem to want to do.  Am I correct?  I have seen too many players that state they want to PvP, yet runs for the hills when it arrives and they get sent home with their tales between their legs and that isn't just in this game.  Rockstar really needs a separate server like they did with the 1st RDR.  

[BropolloCreed79]

8 hours ago, Harley clark said:

Man up and make a posse? Lol I have a posse. We have full time jobs not like all of us can be on all the time. I know us bitching ain’t gonna change it. Just venting bro

Truer words were never spoken.  

Of course, it would also help if I didn't get locked into almost two hours of error codes when I tried to group up with a friend in another session.  Right now, these servers are garbage, beta status or not.

[Kean_1]

1 hour ago, BropolloCreed79 said:

Truer words were never spoken.  

Of course, it would also help if I didn't get locked into almost two hours of error codes when I tried to group up with a friend in another session.  Right now, these servers are garbage, beta status or not.

Yeah, that really sucks.

Friday night when I was experiencing really bad lag, one of my friends logged on.  Too bad that was his first experience with the game that night.  To top it all off, missions wouldn't populate or simply wouldn't work right when they did.  We were also trolled several times.   24 hours later my other friend (first time as well) logged on and we had a blast.  Things were smooth, missions worked and we really didn't run into any trolls.

Personally, in some sessions it seems they are trying to throw too many people together.  Other times (when it's less crowded) everything works better.  .....animals spawn in, missions show in the map and work, griefers are more tolerable (obviously), etc.  I have counted players in each session but that's the way it seems to me at times.  Maybe it had nothing to do with that and each session was full.   ......dunno.

[Harley clark]

Ya know I guess I should be clear cuz I guess I wasn’t originally. I’m not a pussy. I’m not afraid to sit and have an endless gunfight till the dude gives up and runs away. But the reason I made this post was for the kids that look at the map and see me miles from where they’re at and track me down just to kill me for no reason while hunting or trying to do a mission. If I roll into town and I see some players in town I have a shotgun out and ready just in case they’re gonna be stupid  but that’s fine if they shoot at me I shoot back. But what I hate is the posse that purposely camps on a mission start point and just hides behind sh*t like a coward till some Lone Ranger comes along to do the mission then they all pop out and shoot before he can defend himself then go back to hiding 

[YodaMan 3D]

On 12/1/2018 at 6:09 AM, Cliffs said:

And then he went on a forum somewhere and complained about this arsehat named H...C... that shot him because he shot him before....do you see how that works?

And then we would have the full story now wouldn't we.  We could judge for ourselves.  If the game doesn't extablish a balance then players need to be able to vent.  2 sided coin and I personally have no issues hearing both sides.

[Kormath]

Solo/group servers is what's needed.  Once they release those they maybe i'll go back an try online again.  I spent long enough this weekend to go through the intro, get into free roam, get killed repeatedly within 5 minutes of being in free roam, that I won't go back to play RDO.  Hell i didn't even want to play offline after that.  That's the first evening since RDR2 was released i quit playing out of frustration.

I got more entertainment that evening watching Outlander episodes than playing the game.    

[Kean_1]

6 hours ago, BropolloCreed79 said:

Truer words were never spoken.  

Of course, it would also help if I didn't get locked into almost two hours of error codes when I tried to group up with a friend in another session.  Right now, these servers are garbage, beta status or not.

Seems your error code woes may soon be a thing of the past.  ......or at least the focus of the first RDO update this week.  The following was posted by R* today on Twitter:

No mention of more session options but then again, it appears updates will be coming on a frequent basis as the next one after this is scheduled for next week.  

Let's keep the feedback coming folks!!!!!

[BropolloCreed79]

2 hours ago, Harley clark said:

Ya know I guess I should be clear cuz I guess I wasn’t originally. I’m not a pussy.

Nobody with any sort of conscience or rational ability to think would infer that.

2 hours ago, Harley clark said:

But what I hate is the posse that purposely camps on a mission start point and just hides behind sh*t like a coward till some Lone Ranger comes along to do the mission then they all pop out and shoot before he can defend himself then go back to hiding 

Which is a very real problem, and could easily be resolved by removing persistent blips on the mini map, or altering them significantly to function more like they do in Single Player or Story Mode.   Tagging players or groups on the minimap who have obtained a Wanted Level for a set amount of  time (and granting rewards for taking them out) would go a long way to curbing this behavior.

[Kormath]

2 minutes ago, BropolloCreed79 said:

 Tagging players or groups on the minimap who have obtained a Wanted Level for a set amount of  time (and granting rewards for taking them out) would go a long way to curbing this behavior.

They had something similar in GTAO didn't they?  if memory serves the griefers would get tagged with a wanted level and be a red mark on the map.  You got something for killing them, and the law enforcement would also be hunting them as other players were.  

[BropolloCreed79]

2 minutes ago, Kormath said:

They had something similar in GTAO didn't they?  if memory serves the griefers would get tagged with a wanted level and be a red mark on the map.  You got something for killing them, and the law enforcement would also be hunting them as other players were.  

Never played GTA V, so I can't opine on what they did or didn't have.  The last time I went "all in" on a GTA game was Vice City.  Everything else has been pretty derivative, imo.

[Kean_1]

15 minutes ago, Kormath said:

They had something similar in GTAO didn't they?  if memory serves the griefers would get tagged with a wanted level and be a red mark on the map.  You got something for killing them, and the law enforcement would also be hunting them as other players were.  

Yeah, they did although I don't recall the reward.  Can't say I ever felt it was as effective in that game as I think it would in RDO (given all the advanced weapons, vehicles etc. in GTA).  

It's these features in GTA that make me confident that we will at least see some implemented in RDO like the invite only sessions, etc.