YodaMan 3D Posted July 16, 2018 Share Posted July 16, 2018 This weekend I started playing RDR, hoping to get psyched for RDR2. As I was playing somethings came to mind. How long was John out of the Gang? Did the others know he was alive? Cause wouldn't the gang just come to Beechers Hope and try to recruit John back or use it as a hideout. How did they not cross paths before John started hunting them? John hunts in Tall Trees area all the time, at least when I played him he did. Maybe I just didn't remember the story well, but I thought John got caught after being shot after the botched robbery where he got shot. Was that correct? So Bonnie saw John on the Train, assuming she got off at the stop at her ranch, what was Bonnie and Amos doing by the Fort when they found John? Not much that I could see a rancher and her ranch hand would need out there and it would have been way out of her way to just be driving by. Why take him back to their ranch? Wouldn't have been better just to drop him off at Armadillo on their way home. Back then $15 dollars was quite a bit of money. How exactly did John do to pay them back? John rides round the ranch, kills a few rabbits and coyotes. John helps them herd cattle a few times. John then helps them capture some wild horses, (supposedly, I mean you look that there is a ranch nearby one time and Armadillo the next), just saying they may not have be wild. Then Bonnie gives the keeper to John afterwards, ( which back then a good horse was worth killing over back then.) Saves Drew from the barn fire and Bonnie after she was kidnapped. I appreciate and respect that John has so much love and loyalty to his family, but most people would have figured Bonnie is here, I can tap that and the wife would never know. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!Register a new account
Already have an account? Sign in here.Sign In Now