Kormath

probably my memory then I used to clear that ranch every time i went hunting up north for loot and cash. got be to almost too easy, take out the watchman on the tower, sneak down to the brush near the gate south of the tower, shoot the walker there, then the guy in the stables, etc. etc. could clear it and dump all the bodies on the camp fire to clean up the area in under 10 minutes.

I coulda sworn there was one in Hanging Dog Ranch you could use to distract the O'Drisculls, maybe my mind is playing tricks on me though?

i had that happen at one of the random camps, dynamite fixed that, no more crate.

just to clarify You can get the errand boy trophy in the epilogue, but only if you need 1 item to complete it. Uncle will ask you for medicinal cream you can craft at a camp. If you need more than 1 item when you get to the epilogue, you're screwed. Doesn't look like you need to do these for 100% game completion. But for 100% trophies you need to complete 5 camp requests.

that's easily fixed by choosing your weapons before jumping off the horse. it only empties the wheel after a camp or death that i can recall off hand, might be other triggers for that. Pointless, the carcasses would rot and you'd be left with a wagon of putrid flesh. There is no "real open world" game, all games have restrictions and limits to what you can do, so does life. So yeah i guess you could say this is a "real" game.

you do what i did, shoot all you can and then when the ones come in from behind... RUN!! take cover in a spot where you can face both from the same direction, then use the cover and shoot them all dead.

there's a few threads on this here somewhere in the forums, don't think anyone yet has figured out what they're for, or if they're for anything.

camp requests are not broken. I agree with @Foxtrot your stories aren't matching up. You said closing the game and restarting fixed the Pearson request. you need to do that every time you're done playing, otherwise it corrupts the cache and stuff. you should probably clear the cache. If you're on Xbox save your game, then hit the xbox button and scroll down to RDR2 and hit Start button (right one of the start/select buttons) then quit/exit the game. HOld in the power button on the console until it shuts off, then wait about 30 seconds and turn it back on. For the PS, save the game, turn off the console, power it on, start the game. after the RDR2 splash screen (the opening screen) when it turns black press and hold in R1 and L1 until you get the darkness and screen calibration options.

They're just dreaming for a RDR playable game on the PS *cough*shoulda bought an xbox*cough* We won't see another GTA in the near future, maybe not ever. Agreed we'll probably see Bully remastered before anything else from Rockstar.

that horse should be back in the valentine stable for sale at $0.00 you can't lose the DLC horse.

that's what i was thinking too! a corpse washed up on shore or found in the river, minus the bloating.

I love this. "It doesn't work for me (but does for the other millions out there playing) so the game is broken" Your question is answered in your post game says u cant carry any more of that item. that means your inventory is full, go sell all your watches and come back and pick up the one on the table. @Foxtrot answered that for you above. Took 4 or 5 hands for him to talk about his item when i played. Is this a chapter dependent one I'm wondering? I did all of them to get the achievement in chapter 2. I did this one in the evening if i remember right, When i'd go back to camp to turn in the stuff for the upgrades i'd talk to everyone, i think this might be a chapter 2 one also? I don't remember a dominoes table in the other chapters, but i could be wrong as i rarely played at camp played this with her and maybe one other time cause i was bored.

not in the knife section of the weapon wheel with R1/L1?

I gave up on that one, couldn't get 100% anyway with the legendary fish glitched, and that challenge was just pissing me off lol. I'd make it to Lake Owanjila and get jumped by the gang that took over Hanging Dog Ranch, forget their name. or i'd be on the final run past John's house to get to blackwater and a cougar would spawn, so the camera would focus on it for a sec and the horse would run into a boulder beside the road and i'd go flying. Or i'd actually make the full run, on a nice clear sunny day, running beside the road and on the edge of the tracks to avoid puddles, and get no credit.

yep same for me. legendary fishing is pathetically easy. i was hoping for more of a challenge. I usually stand so i can cast at the head of the fish on the map, or as close to that as possible, never failed getting one that way.

that was always my fear, i'd make a heck of a good run and then get stopped there by a train. if you do it in the early morning or evening i haven't seen a train there. during the day they travel that frequently.

You sure it was golden currants? i picked a ton of those at that fallen down fort just west of Van Horn, they're scattered all over that area. i'd pick them all then run over and hunt cougar or whatever in west elizabeth for a day or 2 (in-game time) then go back and pick more to do the crafting part of the herbalist challenge with them.

i see you beat me to it i gave him pretty much same answer as your post above in his post on this in the Questions section.

they do respawn but it's a slow respawn, like 3 or 4 in game days. Gotta give the gators time to get busy and lay more eggs i guess. I did just that, donated a few eggs to Pearson then sold everything else i found. Then i got the exotics missions. Took a while to get all the eggs, there's a guide for the exotics quests that marks where the eggs and orchids spawn, and it's pretty damn accurate for an online guide. i never would have finished that quest line if it weren't for this guide. http://www.powerpyx.com/red-dead-redemption-2-all-exotics-locations/

Found this on a quick google search - eurogamer.net So there's only 14 legendary fish, not 15. Here's the list of all 30 fish in the game - from powerpyx.com - put in a spoiler so this thread isn't super long So if you're missing the 15th fish, that would the regular sockeye salmon. Lot's of places you can catch them at. Between Cumberland Falls and the Diablo Ridge area Lake Owanjila Headwaters of the LIttle Creek River (upstream from Hanging Dog Ranch) Lake Isabella and the rivers/creeks feeding it Headwaters of the Dakota River (From the Inidan Reservation down to Whinyard Straight) O'Creaghs Run Elysian Pool

right. bad choice of words on my part i guess. there won't be a GTA 6 in the near future. There's a number of 'news sites' out there about it, if you can believe anything in the news anymore. The news all depends on who pays more to have their version heard. https://www.altchar.com/games-news/579348/grand-theft-auto-6-not-coming-any-time-soon-due-to-politics So for at least the next 5 years or so Rockstar's focus will be on the Online games - GTA and RDR2

I get the collection part, i've done that with other games, but how is it piracy if you legally obtain the music from another service? Rockstar doesn't own the music, the artist does.

me too! I also drank the brew, and if i recall correctly it knocks you out and you wake up a ways away from the shack. i ran back and all the stuff i had just looted before drinking from cauldron was back, not sure if it whatever took me out away from the shack when i passed out replaced all the items i looted or if they respawned.

not true. if you don't change your outfit or horse and commit crimes in the same area more than a few times, witnesses willI recognize you with a bandanna or a mask on. Rockstar made them somewhat intelligent to look at your clothing, horse, and face.

just saw this snow report, guess i can't complain no more.