Kean_1

I don't have time to respond right now but I will say we don't condone naming & shaming in this forum. I will be deleting your list but will be back to offer advice.

I also recall there was an article or mention somewhere about this. I know it works for your character and I believe there was a specific comment about the horse too.

I fixed the title for you. I don't have an answer for you though.

Well then..... They aren't so hardcore then are they? We're talkin' hardocre players who have been chuggin' along since the release of RDO!!!! Seriously though.... He even admits he's not defining what hardcore is so I don't think his intent was that we read too much into that term. This is obviously just a loose discussion to see how much time players invest in this game.

Good question. Perhaps @Foxtrot may know as I haven't really revisited the campaign since RDO launched. I know Fox is more in touch with that aspect of the game than I am.

Ah..... There it is. Sorry, I didn't doubt you, I just didn't recall reading that. Guess it didn't stick in my mind since it was never a big issue for me as I hadn't had the problems with griefers as some have especially after the radar / blip changes.

....funny. I remember people saying the same thing about GTAO in the early days. Some still did throughout it's life and yet here we are with one of the most successful GaaS models to date in the gaming industry. I rarely buy into these kinds of prophecies from hubbub via the internet/YT. The fact is that some folks will move on from RDO while others will stay. Some folks may come back and new players will join. .....and yeah, there is that chance the game will be a failure although that could be arguable as well as many define that differently. However, if I had to put my money on the experience and track record of a company like R* (with one of the most successful GaaS models in the gaming industry) or internet naysayers to predict RDOs longevity, I'll go with the former. That's not to say that RDO will continue to grow in a direction I personally like but then again, my personal issues (or that of a group) with a game doesn't mean I believe it will fail. I've already shelved this game once and I may likely do it again in the future. ......but like GTAO, I have a feeling I'll keep returning and may even stay a while at times.

I don't recall them saying that those would be removed in the Spring Update but if they are, that would be nice IMO. .....or perhaps at least make it so they are "event-only" where PvP engagements are recognized and expected. Defenders would be expecting a fight but attackers are not penalized for their aggressive actions.

Never had a problem doing them myself either. As for those challenges involving killing other players, I simply never partake in those.

This is new to me but I wouldn't be surprised if this was an exploit they were using. In either case, it appears you still were able to kill them. I would report it to R* though since because if it wasn;t an exploit, it surely is a bug: https://support.rockstargames.com/categories/115001624507?redirect_lang=en_us&_ga=2.47340775.1597511189.1554919231-1719606522.1525287356

.....did I mention deja vu?

I would suggest contacting R* if you want to report a player or issue like this. Unfortunately, I had to take the link down as this sort of falls into the "naming & shaming" rule. If you can blur out the other player's name or wish to describe what you see, that would be fine.

Negative XP Appearing in the Red Dead Online Beta Created April 9, 2019Updated April 9, 2019 Print Question: My Red Dead Online Beta character has a negative XP number being displayed next to their Rank. What should I do? Answer: An issue which appeared to show players receiving negative XP has been resolved. If you are still seeing this, please note that once you've earned enough XP to reach the next Rank level, your XP and Rank will display normally.

If I recall, this 4/9 update was the last in the weekly schedule of updates they announced. .....so, that could mean just about anything but I also reckon it could be that the Spring Update might hit as early as next week if they keep with the every-Tuesday updates. .....but who knows. It's all speculation at this point. I'll wager we will at least have some news next week on future updates (perhaps including the Spring Update) if nothing else. Maybe another "State of the Beta" announcement.

Why is it so hard to imagine that people wouldn't cheat to get where they are in the game? I've heard about a lot of these glitches and exploits but I never used any of them. Why you ask? 1) I don't like the idea of cheating to get ahead. 2) I know that for those that do there is the possibility that the devs could at some point reverse any gains I have been achieved from exploits. 3) I play games for the fun of it. If the journey to get to my next rank, unlock, to earn cash for a purchase, etc. isn't an enjoyable and rewarding experience, I simply won't play. Exploiting glitches is neither fun nor challenging for me so it really doesn't matter how much I gain from them. Rapid advances in level & cash also leave nothing else in the game for me to strive for. I shelved the game a few weeks ago because I came to a point where it felt too repetitive. I'm also not into PvP events so there really hasn't been anything added lately that appeals to me. I will likely revisit the game again after the big Spring Update as I will from time to time after that. RDO will be evolving for a long time into the future and I currently have other things to keep me occupied while I wait for the additional content, changes, etc.

Merged your post with the existing one on this topic.

Sounds like it's just this week.

PLUNDER SHOWDOWN MODE NOW AVAILABLE In the Red Dead Online Beta’s new Showdown Mode Plunder, frontier resources are in short supply - work with your team to fight through opposition and capture supplies from a central location to deliver it to your team’s base. In addition to capturing loot from that central location, you can also use cunning to steal it from your opponent's base. But be careful - when holding you'll be visible to all other players. Keep your Health, Stamina and Dead Eye cores filled and use tonics to boost your tank to gold before making a run for packages and take advantage of team-based Dead Eye Ability cards like Focus Fire that lets your teammates cause a little more damage while your Dead Eye is active. Outfitters across the five states have received the latest shipments of clothing this week: Owanjila Hat Porter Jacket Concho Pants And as added bonuses this week, access for all coats, holsters, boots & gloves otherwise up to Rank 40 will be available to all players - grab any of these styles until April 15th. For higher ranking players, the Turkoman, Missouri Fox Trotter and Arabian Horses are being lowered to Rank 40, while Volatile Dynamite, Incendiary Buckshot, Explosive Slug, Express Explosive, and Dynamite Arrow pamphlets are all lowered to Rank 60.

HI Marcos and welcome to RDR2.org. You might want to also open a trouble ticket with R* Support while you wait for a response from our members. ....although there is no guarantee someone here will have an answer to your problem. All the more reason to reach out to R* CS too. https://support.rockstargames.com/categories/115001624507?redirect_lang=en_us&_ga=2.11899831.2076387041.1554766320-1719606522.1525287356

Just a suggestion but you might want to fill out the rest of your profile with your console info and gamertag if you so choose. It's helps especially when trying to find others to play with, etc.

The Colt SAA / Peacemaker is already represented in the game as the Cattleman. .....just as the Lancaster represents the Winchester 1866 and the Litchfield is the Henry, etc. Some of the weapons they used their real life counterpart names and others they didn't.

Moving this to the RDR2 section instead of online. RDO does not have legendary animals or trappers. The closest thing are the ones you face in the stranger missions but still, those are not the same thing.

No problem. Removed it for you.

Just contact myself or another mod and we'll be happy to help you. Better yet, report your own post as a duplicate and it will go into an inbox that we all see. btw, here's the like to R* CS that I mentioned: https://support.rockstargames.com/categories/115001624507?redirect_lang=en_us&_ga=2.181633319.1461521640.1554662663-1719606522.1525287356

I closed the other thread you created @dobo8080as it was a duplicate of this one. As for the problem with the recipe, I would suggest contacting R* Customer Support to see if they can help you. Unless someone here can point out something you are missing, they will be the only ones who may be able to get this straightened out for you.