Tom Dooley

" Game has made me cold hearted recently I'm MUCH more likely to shoot first anymore. " This is what a game like this does to us. And the sad thing is that we do not have a separate game-brain or memory so it will actually influence in our daily life. Rockstar knows what they are doing.

This happened to me too, but the horse resurrected a bit later

Rockstar realism at it`s best I guess

Grumpy old man will try to find you, gt Willy Nikkersen based in norway

My characters are true western types, seasoned guys. No [REMOVED] hairstyles, have a beard and/or a moustache, authentic western-style clothing. Wery unlike those posers dressed up in medival costumes with fancy hats shooting or throwing dynamite at everything that moves. Different servers for authentic players & brats would solve a lot but from rockstar? Not likely

Exactly. All these childish "extras" simply ruins the games autencity, makes it into a kind of western-on-acids game for psycopats. Just like rockstar intended

I`ve tryed to kick it only to end up with an one star corpse. Dirty boots mybe?

Spot on, guess that`s the liqour speaking 🙄

The fine thing with herbs is that they do not attack you. But you need still to be careful with eating some of them, they might poison you.

This is mybe the most pathetic side of the game as it is now. You can shot any animal and sell it, pick and sell vegetables, catch fish or steal valuables. But if you catch and tame a wild horse it`s not worth a penny.

I agree in everything. On one side rockstar has made the game wery unfunny and on the other side the online part needs a sociopath-filter

She will have to catch yhose herbs with her lasso as soon as she has cleared out how to establis dead-eye. Life ain`t easy

Abilitycards is a gamekiller. Like legaized cheats. I`ve left the online-game bcs of this, won`t look back

These guys are not human. I`ve seen them take five good hits from a Bolt Action rifle too.

Back on topic; since money is an issue, what about adding gold-digging as an option in free roam. Would be an eldorado for griefers too, just like it was back then

You was given the information in the small saloon in Valentine. Open your sackel and read the cards youtube is your friend:

Named my character Willie so his horse had to be Waylon. His female horse though was named Madeleine since she get his stuff stowed onto her

I`ve never bought a horse in story mode. good horses can be found easily. One of the better horses is actually given when this random guy gets kicked and killed by his horse. Catch it and stable it, and fill up your stable with decent horses

Believe it or not folks, I`ve found Gavin. Mybe not the RDR-Gavin but still. He was playing on a british soccerteam in Football Manager 2005

Hmm, wonder if I should buy a micahphone

Old Heep, needs to be played LOUD!

Hmm, does this have something to do with settings? Like setting horse control to horse-relative?

RorshachFromHell said: "This guy took 5-6 shots from both of us and never went down. turned around and killed us with 1 pistol round each.." Yup, those abilitycards is like playing with cheats on, a bit from any kind of realism. And since Rockstar rewards those griefers for killing other players..

Shooting from horseback? The mongoleans were known for their remarkable skills firing their bows from horseback. If you`ve spendt most of your life on a horseback then shooting is no challenge, but the "red dot" might be a bit bigger. About free aiming; can be learned but as others says it is not easy with a controller.

It could have been so if the "abilities" were a bit moore limited but no. Have met players were my guns didn`t function, autoaim didn`t work a.s.o. Makes you wonder the first time but when you realise what`s going on it feels too unrealistic. A gamekiller..