Truth

You couldn't tell the difference on a 4k tv?

If not, @Bonzai is going to be PIIIISSSED...

I like that last one: "I tried dynamite and he just runs away too quickly for it to blow him off the ledge." I haven't encountered this guy yet, so I can't even picture the angle or anything to begin trying to figure it out. Lasso and dynamite were my only ideas... Maybe a dynamite arrow or some explosive rounds? I need to find a screenshot of this guy...

And I felt so clever when I suggested it...

The earlier the better. Probably not as worthwhile as you progress. I'm still in chapter 2, so I still have most of the game to take advantage of the extra space. The first upgrade is nice (lets you hold an extra 10 of each item), but the Legend of the East Satchel is almost like a cheat code (99 of each item).

THAT was a fun mission... If all else fails, just die a few times and you'll be given the extra option to skip that portion of the mission and continue on. I think you'll still have to free him, but you'll be able to skip the (in my opinion) fun part.

You could always just shoot it if it's that important. I doubt they would let you sell something you got as a preorder bonus...

Those are just from the legendary animals. I skipped that and upgraded my satchel first. It took A LOT of time hunting, but it was totally worth it in my opinion. I'll never have to leave an item behind again.

I don't KNOW that it died, that's just what I'm assuming. Take it as a lesson that YOU SHOULD ALWAYS MANUALLY SAVE before AND after significant events. I save every few minutes to avoid the hassle you're going through now.

It's all there:

Depends on the mission. If it's part of the story, you'll have to get through it to progress. If it's a side mission, you should be able to ignore it. Are you stuck because you're having trouble with something, or because of a bug? Maybe someone here will be able to help you with a little more information.

You're horse probably died...

Can you lasso him and pull him down?

When I got my own apartment a few months back, I got a 65" 4k for my living room. I haven't really been able to take advantage of the 4k yet though. Some netflix shows stream in 4k, but that's about all I have access to. Getting the xbox one x would (help) justify purchasing such a ridiculous tv if nothing else. Looks like it will be on sale next week for $400. I might give in when that happens... Plus that means I can give my xbox one to my nephew and maybe start playing some games with him. He's still stuck on the 360 that I gave him like 3 years ago...

Ah, got it. I knew that sounded too simple.

So you just shoot him? I was going to suggest that but figured I would look like an ass lol

Did you finish upgrading yours?

https://www.vg247.com/2018/11/13/red-dead-redemption-2-talismans-trinkets-perks/

I keep thinking about upgrading to the x, but it's still over $400 everywhere (even used)... Just looked up the ps4 pro, there's a bundle with rdr2 for $400... I'm VERY tempted to just make the jump to ps4...

This is why I normally have my varmint rifle on hand. I did the same thing, but I haven't gotten to that challenge yet lol This is the only reason I've spotted any birds. No way in hell would I be able to study them. I see movement and let the crazy auto aim take care of the rest.

People should always do this when they're done playing (instead of just turning off their xbox). It prevents a lot of bugs.

I can't really answer that because I've only really played on xbox. If you REALLY want my opinion, you'll have to send me a ps4 so I can compare the 2. I'll also take an amazon gift card for the amount!

Damn, I never thought of that!!!

That is definitely the most creative way to do it that I've heard. Way to think out of the box!

First off, respect. Have you tried: Also, wear a mask to avoid the bounties.