BropolloCreed79

I have found this to be the most efficient method, especially on small-game critters. The elevation from horseback makes it easier to pick them up as they move through the grass/underbrush when your Eagle Eye is on cooldown.

I have shot my share of fellow gamblers and dealers in the game. It's... therapeutic.

If you're in the continental US, I'll send you some after I go Bambi Blasting the Monday after Thanksgiving. Some of us have impeccable aim IRL. Of course, an red dot scope on a picatinny rail with a bolt action Mossberg (with a rifled barrel) tend to make it easier than taking a photo, but still...

Because improperly harvested venison tastes terrible, while rabbit is succulent and delicious. It's like duck, but a tad less fatty.

Is it sad and pathetic that I know that's supposed to be Barry Bonds? Also, Hank Scorpio is the greatest Simpsons character ever, and I have his action figure as proof.

They do. Which reminds me: I need to do more of those "suicide by horse" videos.

Mrs. Creed came downstairs to see what I was laughing at when it happened. And now that it's immortalized on YT, my kids find it utterly hilarious.

Thanks. I'm a crusty old fart who doesn't have the time or skill that these young 14-year old whippersnappers hooped up on Adderall and Redbull do to devote to "git gud". I've also come to appreciate craftsmanship as I age: 16-uear aged single malt scotch, charcuterie based pizza, RDR2... When a person or group of people throw their passion fully into a project, it often creates something beautiful that should be cherished and recognized. Anyone could have taken GTA and just reskinned it with cowboys and horses, and nobody would have batted an eye. Instead, we have been given the culmination of a decade's worth of tireless devotion to creating a unique experience that couldn't be a bigger departure from GTA if they had tried. And it is absolutely stunning. There's nothing wrong with GTA or the people who prefer the experience it offers. But this? This is an achievement in storytelling and world building that I haven't experienced in gaming in at least a decade. I was never over excited for this game. It was a simple curiosity that led me to preorder; and the promise that the single player story would be focus at launch. GTA was never my cup of tea, but I can appreciate it for what it is. RDR2 isn't the best game I've ever played (it may be soon, but I can't assess half a game and need to play online to make a fully formed opinion), but it's eclipsed everything else from this current console generation. It may not have been a selling point for me, bit I can't ignore how the pace allows me to just take EVERYTHING in. And the attention to detail can't be overlooked. I've expounded upon this at length previously, but this game has literally left NOTHING to chance; each and every aesthetic choice feels deliberately calculated, and thus far has created a unique experience (for me at least) that is unlikely to be matched by any game for the foreseeable future. I am simply awestruck by this game. Were I capable of cying, it would have reduced me to tears multiple times already in it's splendor and majesty.

Lucky you. If I let Mrs. Creed control the alcohol stock in Casa de Creed, we'd have nothing but gin and Whiteclaw. A far cry from the days of our courtship when her fridge was magical and never seemed to run out of Guinness...

I go by how much alcohol I've consumed. Right now, I'm at about 35 drinks since the game launched three weeks ago.

I offer, as a humble suggestion, something Arthur himself probably would have consumed on his journey (and it's dirt cheap too!) Noted enthusiasts include: Gunfighter and gambler Doc Holliday Old West outlaw Johnny Ringo Civil War general and U.S. President Ulysses S. Grant U.S. President John F. Kennedy U.S. Secretary of State John Foster Dulles

First, thanks for using the Spoiler Tool! I randomly encountered the same thing on one of my lazy exploration excursions. I even tried to be humane and blow it up with dynamite. Sadly, the interaction with it seems locked for me, but I'm only on Chapter 2, so it may come up again later in the story.

Oh, I'm attached to Arnold (as in Schwarzenegger) my Dutch Drafthorse, but the thrill of chasing down that horse, and the atmosphere, the visuals.... I'm getting chills just thinking about it again. It may depend on the terrain where you make the attempt. I know it can spawn in multiple areas, and I (foolishly) tried mine in the far north where the snow came up to my knees, and the damn thing was running a picket fence through trees. That white on white is pretty tough to track when you've been roleplaying Arthur IRL as a cantankerous middle aged man with borderline alcoholism.

Lucky bastard. It took me 45 minutes, and I went through three beers chasing it.

The real question is, was it harder than which was one of the most exhaustive things I've encountered in a game in YEARS. Edit: it's 12 days to gun season on deer in Ohio, and I'm ready to roll. FYI, skinning a deer is not as easy as Arthur makes it look.

The only person I care about less than Pearson is Micah. The only ones I value at all are Charles and Josiah. Oh, and my drinking buddy, Lenny. There's times I just want to slap Dutch in the face. He's such a manipulative tool, it makes me want to torch his tent and stick that pipe in an uncomfortable place (like the back of a Volkswagen?) Strauss just gives me the creeps. Javier seems like an opportunistic scumbag, but what do I know, I'm only on Chapter 2. Uncle Bill is a lazy bum. The only person lazier is Dutch.

It's not just you. The dynamic lighting in the second picture is far superior. Everything in the first one is flat light.

Alcohol can do that for you, too.

Not even the satisfaction of a job well done?

If I run across him, I'll call him "Pony Boy" and repeatedly tell him to "Stay Golden".

The same holds true of using hair growth tonics. I've been in Chapter 2 for over two weeks now, and no matter how much hair tonic I take, my beard is stuck at a solid 7. I tried 6 tonics a day for a week in-game, with no further results (Dutch turned into a real A-hole when I did that, complaining about not "tithing the box" and all that jazz--really wanted to slit his belly over his insolence).

Pacing in this game is a sensitive and divisive topic. Some folks find the game irreparably slow, seemingly preferring the reckless and wild abandon of GTA or FPS games. Others, like myself, are fully immersed in what R* and Take Two have done here. The pacing is glorious; and what happened to me last night was a perfect example of how this game manages to continually surprise, delight, and keep me on the edge of sleep deprivation despite all efforts to put the controller down at a reasonable hour. Riding down out of the mountains last night after finishing up the third leg of I was heading south out of the snow covered peaks towards Lake Isabella, girding myself for the long, arduous (and somewhat boring) ride back to Valentine, when heavy fog rolled in (taking a moment aside here to acknowledge the amazing job done with the randomized weather patterns in this game--absolutely phenomenal). I was trotting along with a newer horse that I was leveling up to sell off to the farrier, when a large, fleeting shadow flickered off to my left. Still needing perfect elk pelts and having seen a few wandering about in the area, I paused momentarily to draw my rifle when I saw her, the elusive Having not actively sought her out before, I was stunned. Like a ghost in the mist, she appeared and dashed off into the vapor--I quickly dismounted and pursued on foot (again, the tooltips here did an excellent job guiding me through the process). Continually, my exuberance got the best of me and I plunged ahead in the deep snow, regardless of the potential of scaring her off yet again. Finally, after several missteps and repeated spooks, I settled into a slow rhythm and made my way ever so closer to her. And then I mounted. A minor gripe is that the experience of taming the horse is poorly explained in the tooltips, and should have been better worded for clarity. Having not had to previously tame a horse in the game, the experience was incredibly frustrating and defeating as she bucked me off and tore into the trees with wild abandon (if there's one criticism about the experience, it's that they probably should have had this be a side job or quest somewhat early in the game--to break horses for the farrier in Valentine for money). Down, but not defeated, I pursued her. Two more times I got close enough to mount before she took off as I prepared to try and mount again. I was thirty minutes in--over a day had passed in-game tracking this elusive creature by foot, being taunted and teased the whole way, but I would not be dissuaded. I was in it to win it, no matter how long it took. Finally, I had a revelation--instead of waiting for the tooltip to tell me when to attempt a mount, I was going to just "go for it". I approached slowly and cautiously (yet again, for what seemed like the tenth or eleventh time), and as I got within reach, as she reared up and prepared to take off, I leaped and was met with success! Throwing caution to the wind I trusted my gut and rode out the maelstrom as she fought to be free of me--for what seemed to be an eternity, I was locked in a contest of wills; me, or this wild, untamed horse. And in a flash, it was over. She settled into an amicable trot as we continued to bond back down the mountain to where I had left my other horse cold, tired, and alone for two days (I felt a little guilty about that part of it, because now that horse was "old and busted"--unlikely to be ridden again, and my recen acquisition was "the new hotness") . Forty-five minutes of effort culminated in the capture of this beautiful, elusive creature. It was exhilarating. A purely random encounter that I was unprepared for turned into the most engaging and rewarding experience I've had in the game after almost three weeks of playing on a daily basis. An experience that was more fulfilling than ENTIRE GAMES by other studios and publishers--curiously enough, an event devoid of violence or mayhem (in a game stuffed full of it), which in and of itself is a testament to the design of the game and the level of thought and detail that underpin the many and varied systems on display. Oh, and as an added bonus, on my way back to Valentine, I also encountered As if the day couldn't get any better. Once I returned to Valentine, I immediately rode to the stables to sell my "old and busted" horse, and rechristen my newest acquisition "Ghost". After all, I've always wanted to be a "Ghost Rider". TL: DR: Epilogue to the story. After handling the horse issue, I rode to the Trapper to sell off the Legendary Hide I had acquired on my journey. As I closed in, the Stranger Mission popped up on my radar. I had the benefit of having some foliage between us, so I approached them from behind. When I got close enough, i just listened to them for a bit. What happened next was nothing short of high comedy as I also remembered to capture the video of this, so once I have the time later, I'll trim it down and upload it, because it was damn hilarious! Edit:

I would play this mode exclusively.

I miss the original Xbox Fat Controllers. No, not this Fat Controller: THIS Fat Controller: LOOK AT THIS THING. IT'S MAGNIFICENT!!! I miss that beauty every day. I'm a big dude with abnormally large hands, and this was, by far, the best controller ever designed for freaks like me.

That was my point. PAL is only 50 fps. NTSC is 60. Because Take Two and R* are NA based, I'm wondering if the native systems being in NTSC are part of the problem with the graphical issues when the signal is ported to PAL. I'm not experiencing the issues others are, but I don't have a PS Pro. I'm on a 4K HDR set that upscales the native image from the standard PS4, and it looks amazing--all without the pixelating issues that are being reported when the "fake" 4K is being pumped out by the PS Pro. Without running the tests myself, I can't be certain. But you indicated you were in Spain, so the first thought in my mind was "PAL/NTSC". 10 fps on an output signal may not be distinguishable to the human eye in most contexts, but that doesn't mean it can't cause issues with processing if it's not planned for in development.