Truth

I would assume so... Best bet is to just keep robbing people I guess lol

From the xbox one x (no spoilers, just using the tool): I was riding full speed and noticed a trail behind me (mentioned before). You can kind of see it in the second picture, but it was WAY worse than it appears. I could literally see 3-4 copies of me in the trail. Regardless of that, the amount of blur in these screenshots is ridiculous. I guess that's to make it run more smoothly? Edit: I guess I never really noticed it because I didn't use cinematic mode too often. When I did, I wasn't paying attention to the tv.

For that challenge, I just walked around saint Dennis and robbed 5 people... I didn't think stores would count.

I'm so conflicted!!!

I just noticed this in in cinematic view. There are certain instances (mostly when it pans to a side view) that there is a "ghostly trail" behind me and my horse. There's definitely something going on there.

I was at a loss until you said that. The next unlock that you mentioned allows you to remain in dead eye after shooting, so you're able to shoot each target without marking it.

Who needs a scope with such great Auto aim? Lol I only used the bow on cougars for that challenge.

https://gph.is/2p6q53C

Always looking for shortcuts... lol

I always have trouble with timing the bow in dead eye. Rifle is basically a guaranteed headshot though.

Have you tried down?

That's in October... I talked it over with my buddy and came up with THE BEST plan. I'll make it a day after Christmas present! That way he gets to "win" Christmas, my nephew still gets the upgrade, and I piss off my brother more than I ever could've dreamed!

I'm not looking forward to those gambler challenges... I think the exotics are also going to be a pain in the ass.

Just don't make the mistake of stocking up on everything like I did. Focus on the extra stuff (challenges, stranger missions, special items, etc) but don't worry about money or anything. I wanted to get through the missions before I started forgetting what was going on. Once I got back to them, I couldn't stop lol I'll do another play through soon enough, I only have a few more things to wrap up. I'm at 92.3% total completion.

@Volt I strongly advise ignoring the extra stuff right now and getting through chapter 6. That last mission was ****ing awesome!

I hear you there. I was under the impression there would be more to upgrade later in the story, so I dumped $2000 into the camp...

I had a long response to this, but accidentally reloaded the page and it disappeared... You should be able to access the gunslinger missions. I'd start there if you want pistols/revolvers. I'm pretty sure you can just buy the Lancaster in chapter 4. That's my go-to because it's more general purpose. Great range (especially with a scope) and speed. If you're looking for total completion, there are a few guns that can be missed easily. I missed one in chapter 3, so I might have to restart...

Like @Vaderspupil said, you can't just keep reeling it in. Use the left stick to pull it where you want and wait for it to stop resisting. Then reel it in quickly, pulling back on the left stick as you go (that pulls the fish closer to you and makes it easier to reel in). If your controller is vibrating, you should wait. Smaller fish don't seem to break the line either way though.

Are there multiple ways to obtain guns? I thought it was either through the store or through missions (other than a few). Which guns are "the best"? I never really compared. I only really use the Springfield rifle, the Lancaster repeater, or the varmint rifle.

Just wait, they get worse...

This one gave me trouble as well. I think I finally found someone there in the middle of the day. Seemed to only be for a small amount of time though because I went back there several times before finding anyone. I'd suggest just camping out until morning and waiting around until somebody goes there. Edit: My issue was in Strawberry, but it was the same problem.

The only person I care to go big for is my nephew. I was planning on giving him my Xbox one since I just upgraded to the x. Apparently my (stubborn as ****) brother got him some games for his 360, so he told me not to give him the one... Now I'm kind of ****ed since everyone else already got him everything...

Check your settings. Worked fine for me in story mode last night.

I played this morning with no issues, but I'm not sure that the update was out yet. I'm a little worried now though...

Sounds like you'll fit in just fine!