Leaderboard

higher

I read and hear all these complaints about lack of content, payout, etc from RDRO. I can agree with this to a point, but where most people lose me is when they compare it to GTAO. GTAO has been out for 5 years. You can't fairly compare the two games. I think people have lost their memories of when GTAO first launched. While I agree, there were more missions when it first launched than are available in RDRO, it's not like they were overflowing. Also, lets not forget the payouts those missions had. They were just as bad as RDRO's before the economy patch. Hell, I couldn't tell you how many days were spent running nothing but Violent Ducts over and over and over and over and over because it was the only decent paying mission. As for content, lets not forget, it took 1.5 YEARS to get Heists added into GTAO. Heists were a talking point of R*'s from the beginning. I think people need to slow their roll and attention spans a bit for RDRO. Of course, I also think R* could be a little more forthcoming in both content area, as well as the information area. Just my 2 cents. That I got off that NPC I just shot in the face.

I would like to see some things added to really immerse us into the game in a roleplaying kind of way. Right now, I think the game is in a barebones form being in beta but I can see them adding a lot of things to really push that RPG aspect of the game.

Folks digging around in files found placeholders for properties numbered 1 through 10 with this format: This was back in October 2018. There were also similar placeholders for various types of wagons, etc. ....so, this could be a possible sign of things to come that they are planning.

....just glad items like explosive ammo are severely limited.

Hi Goober, First of all, welcome. This site is a wealth of information and generally speaking, the community is a great group of folks. Please note however, that this is a fan site and not a Rockstar official forum. If you wish to provide feedback on the beta (and I encourage you to), here is a link: https://www.rockstargames.com/reddeadredemption2/online/feedback?step=f2e50892 There is also a lot of information at RDR2.org that can help you overcome the issue some have with what we call griefers and trolls. I would also recommend trying to seek out online friends who you share similar interests with so you can explore and do activities with a group vs. solo. RDO is much more rewarding that way and safer with the added security a posse provides. https://www.rdr2.org/forums/clubs/ If you're on PS4, feel free to join ours (my PSN Community is linked within): Please note that R* has also announced new anti-griefing measures that they will be impletning soon that will hopefully mitigate the issue: https://www.rockstargames.com/newswire/article/60804/Red-Dead-Online-Beta-Update Hope this helps.

I think it's rediculous that I have a hundred dollars in hides on my horse cone into a town to sell them n get shot by some a hole n bam all my hides are gone and I'm out of that money maybe make it so we can have a friendly Lobby or something bcuz this is not fair spend two hours hunting n lose everything because someone wants to be a jerk n shoot you for nothing

A little cave built into a small cliff side. And in that little cave.... A certain time-traveling Delorean.

Hell No! Cause then it is a matter of time before it would be put into the game and then we'll have players flying over and dropping dynamite out of the door. No Thanks!

WehTuFat's (now my primary gamertag) a female character whom I named Kyenne Peppers

Might depend on how far away you spawn from your horse. Maybe that's why some griefers kill my horse when I'm loaded with pelts.

I name mine after alcoholic drinks... When I played a guy it's Jose Cuervo, Horse is Tequila, when I play a girl it's Koko Lopez (A spin on the coco Lopez drink mix). Koko also means black foot, or dark in native American if I'm not mistaken. I tried to make them spanish/native American looking.

I hate to tell you this Chris but mine is named Hedley Lamar

Well at the moment there isn't. But R* has picked up some nasty habbits from GTA O. At some point.. (Can't remember when). R* started to drip feed their content in GTA O in updates. Even tho their updates have all the content in game. Like the new Arena Wars update. Everything is in the update, it just locked so they can drip feed it. IMO R* isn't update RDO at the moment, so that players will jump onto GTA O and hopefully buy some cash cards. Im willing to bet right now, the next RD O will happen after shortly after last drip fed vehicle added to GTA O in the Arena Wars up date. Which is the RC car. When R* adds its next update.. They will no doubt drip feed some content. I bet R* does have a lot of content ready for RD O. They are just going to drip feed it all for the sake of drip feeding it. Then slow the updates when GTA O gets another update.

A building kit for single player? Log, Craftsman, Victorian, commercial style prefabs. Fences, plant material, road building, bridges etc. Fallout for pioneers. Marston gets a house, I want a house. Watering his garden doesnt benefit me. Integrate farm products into the economy. Raise my own pigs to sell to the butcher. Get me some farmer pants and let me whistle the Green Acres song while I scoop up cow sh!t.

I think Anthem blows rdrO off its socks. I'm waiting for it,when its out i put rdr2 under a rock next to gtav.

You're right, it isn't a big deal. ....and certainly nothing you should get grief over IMO. I'll move it now. Welcome to the forums btw. It's good to have you here.

Would love to see the ability to raise and sell cattle and sheep , catch wild horses to keep , and of course protect ! Lol also fishing ternys , wagon races , hidden caves to explore and possibly mine ? Just a couple from my wish list.

^ This !! Stop letting R* off the hook with this Beta crap. Beta testing is performed on a completed project to test its performance, RDRO is far from completed, It was released unfinished to appease investors. RDRO is much closer to the cash grab that GTAO became than the GTAO that released.

Thank you, I had no idea and I did so much searching lol. Thanks!

Unfortunately mate we have these tossers in the game. I don't know what level you are if you play on PS4 send me friend request. dredd_fan

You can also just go fishing at Quaker's Cove near Blackwater or up at O'Creaghs Run by Hamish's hut. At QC you get steelhead trout and sockeye salmon at OCR. They are $2.50 each. The max is 10 fish you can carry. At these locations you can also catch rock bass, smallmouth bass, perch, bluegill and both types of pickerels. 10 of each will net you in total about $65. The cool thing about this method is if a player shoots you. You will keep the fish you have caught and lose nothing. I find hunting too limiting and of course don't do it, for the reasons you have outlined above.

I feel you dude. You will find people here who aren't like that online. I know exactly what you mean. I love the hunting aspect of the game and I am always getting screwed over by immature players who got nothing better to do. It can be rather annoying.

Thanks but it won't make a bit of difference unless more do too. https://www.rockstargames.com/reddeadredemption2/online/feedback?step=f2e50892

....so I guess there is no option to disable then. I know there is an option to vote kick and we've always tried to ready up as soon as possible but seems like a real crappy way to do it (e.g. kicking players). Thanks for the info though. I guess I'll submit this to R* as another feedback item.

Good call but he's asking about craftable ammo. Could be out of curiosity for defensive purposes and/or maybe hasn't attained the level yet, etc. I recall hearing that explosive ammo is limited to something around 10 rounds per weapon. Can't say the same for split ammo, etc.

On ps4 you have to push square to enable matchmaking. Simply have all posse members ready up ,if random gets in push left on thumb pad to view players , select random and vote to kick. All members must vote quickly. Hope this helps.

As of right now we don't know all of their plans. Like with GTAO, they had campaign dlcs and scrapped them to persue PvP options, they needed players to focus on Shark Cards and not on DLCs.

We are proud to announce the grand opening of our new place in Emerald. Come on in and and let Mary-Beth mix you up a Guarma and Tonic or just draw you a tepid glass of beer from our taps. In the mood for something from our kitchen? Have Chef Pearson prepare you a mint infused loin of pork with assorted Offal and baked beans. We run a special of Gritty Fish and Bisquits every Friday for just 37 cents. Want to just kick back and contemplate the meaning of life? Enter our smoking lounge and try our Emerald Green Hybrid. On a budget? Our ditch weed is always on the house. We are located at 3 North Emerald Road accross the street from the House of Horns. Open 24/7/365. Cash payments only!

Elected officials--at any level-- who promote and protect illegal activity should be criminally charged.

Hey bud we have found a way to have the server all to yourself. Simply start a teddy Brown mission and don't follow Harley up the trail. He will stay put untill you return to him. Freeing you up to hunt , fish . pick herbs , or whatever you fancy for as long as you like ! You need everyone on the same tactic thoe. If not your cup of tea join us at western avengers posse or ghostly guns posse. We play on est time. Ps4. Carry on good sir !

Good stuff bro ! I'm with you that these names should show in game !

Make sure you're telling Rockstar how you feel: https://www.rockstargames.com/reddeadredemption2/online/feedback?step=f2e50892

That. It's still a beta.

You can't compare the two for the simple fact that RDRO is NOT a complete game. I see and hear it all the time. People are saying GTAO is "way better" but they are not giving the devs a chance to even finish the game. They opened it up rather than making us wait another 4 to 6 months. I think that was rather generous on their part.

If you're looking to start anew and play from start to finish as disreputable, now would be the time while online is still in its infancy. It'll probably be a few more weeks before we get any kind of substantial content update. If you're not in a rush to unlock everything online, there's no need to power level. That's why I just play a little here and there while theres nothing new, only 46 right now online.

what burns me up are the idiots that don't understand what racism is but yell at people for being racist. my favorite (if you can call it that) "Your racist for talking about Muslims", no that's a religion not a race.....

There is much more to come. I would suggest reading through the Beta Updates on R*s Newswire site if you want to catch up on all the news that has so far been shared with the community: https://www.rockstargames.com/newswire/tags/716 Just remember that RDO is a work in progress and still in development. It's not the same as other console games folks may be used to where betas are mainly to help market the game and stress test servers. ....with few (if any) changes made by release a couple weeks or so later.

Cannot say enough good things about this game. It was so worth the money. I cannot stop playing. I have played through to the Epilogues now four times and have just started a fifth game. I will probably never have 100% completion as there are so many challenges I just haven't gotten to yet. Wow .. Rockstar .. all I can say is WOW .. what a game. Lengthy post warning - ramblings that no one will care about but I want to do it any way - LOL Be Careful Where You Sleep .. Some of these areas are just plain creepy and the background music doesn't help either .. LOL .. on my last play through I found myself in what seemed to be a very peaceful and green part of the map somewhere near the Elysian Pool (I had just caught a legendary fish) and it was getting quite late so I decided to have Arthur make camp. As he was about to brew some coffee … WTF .. I lost control of Arthur and found these two nasty dudes pointing guns at him and threatening to shoot him if he ever made camp there again. They literally came right up behind him. I never had this happen before on the previous plays, most likely because I just hadn't been in that area at that time of the evening before .. and it scared the holy crap out of me. I was not expecting that. Well Done Rockstar … LOL serves me right for taking for granted this camping in the wilderness thing. I, of course, had Arthur deliberately make camp again and this time they came up and started shooting so we gunned them both down, looted them and dumped their corpses a fair bit away so he wouldn't have to sleep next to them. Talk about AHHHHHH moment. A Horse Is A Horse .. So many things have been posted about the horses and I have to say that I am very glad there are so many different types available. I want to try them all actually. I did catch and break the white Arabian but after riding her around for awhile I don't think she is as much fun as the American standardbred. Also, she is quite small and Arthur looks really odd on her (or at least to me any way). Once bonded, the standardbred is a great horse to ride and is quite suitable for the majority of the tasks you have in the basic story mode. This horse has managed to not dump Arthur during some pretty stressful and chaotic moments in the game. The exception is the exploding wagon the Lemoyne raiders throw your way but it is forgivable. In the beginning, when you first go to Valentine with Hosea and buy Arthur a horse I actually spend the 150.00 right off and get the dappled palomino American standardbred. This is the horse that I have Arthur ride for the majority of the game and at the very end. I sell the brown and white Tennessee walker that you get from Adler Ranch in Chapter One and I ignore the free horses that are available if you have the Ultimate Edition. I ignore them because you cannot later sell them until way late in the game and they take up stable space. I like to keep stable space available in case I come across a horse I think I would like Arthur to ride around on for awhile. So far I have had Arthur ride the grey Thoroughbred (stolen after Charles and Arthur kill the scumbag bison hunters), a splashed overo blk & white paint horse (stolen from a guy camping near the beach below Flatneck station), the Andalusian (purchased from the stables near Strawberry), the white Arabian (caught near Lake Isabella in the West Grizzlies), the black Arabian and gold Turkoman (both purchased at the livery in Saint Denis) and a few others as and when I feel like a change up. I even stole the buckskin standardbred from the house robbery with Javier .. he was tethered behind the main house. I am just really partial to the standardbred and I am a creature of habit. Now .. in this latest game I am playing I stumbled across a wild solid black American standardbred while camping near Hanging Dog Ranch. I was so happy. Caught her, broke her, threw Arthur's saddle on her and then made a straight run to the nearest stable to make sure I didn't lose her .. so for this new game I have both Palomino and solid black standardbreds … so much fun. I might now sell the white Arabian as I don't think I will use her this game. If I could have one wish, it would be that we could have more stable space or at least be able to own as many horses as we wanted at Beecher's Hope. To each his or her own for this game and there is a horse for everyone .. so brilliant. Guns .. My favourite guns .. Lancaster repeater (except for hunting), dual wielding the sawed off shotguns (except when shooting bottles off the two brother's heads or disarming Jamie after the chase from the Chelonians - don't do that as they all die instantly from the scatter), and Otis Miller's golden revolver which I really want Arthur to have. I wish Arthur could go to New Austin .. at least to finish hunting for legendary animals and fish, find the remaining dinosaur bones and to get that damn golden gun etc. Scary Hype .. Read about all of the creepy cabins, most of which I had not gone in to before and decided to just suck it up and go in to some of them whether I was scared or not. Really not so bad. Echo's Vetter was probably the one that made me jump the worst but .. all of you know why .. LOL .. and then I read some postings about Fir Rise and of the creepy voices and evil laughter. People were chatting back and forth about what could be going on in the barn you cant get into. I went there and immediately realized it is Deborah MacGuiness - the crazy dinosaur lady. It is not so creepy any more actually and it did dawn on me that she does tell Arthur where to send the bones and mentions Fir Rise. Can't believe I forgot about that until I got there. I actually like Deborah MacGuiness and love the bone challenge. Now the one that does creep me out is the freaking taxidermist. That lady is a nutter. The squirrel challenge is quite hysterical, however. Wishes .. things I would love to see added to the story mode More Arthur DLC .. I don't want to stop playing as Arthur. Sorry John but I never played RDR and so I was never attached to John's character. I love Arthur and try to play as much of the game and complete as many of the challenges as Arthur as I can. I, therefore, want to be able to enter New Austin as Arthur - doesn't have to be Blackwater but areas where we can enter and pick up the things we need to complete a couple of the challenges. I would like Arthur to see Deborah MacGuiness again. I did see someone's video of Arthur meeting Deborah again but I cant figure out how they did that when Arthur cant get in to New Austin without being gunned down. If I am missing a trick here can someone help … ; ) More Black Belle and Arthur scenes. That is one cool lady and I think she and Arthur could have had some adventures. I love what he writes about her in his journal. Maybe they could do a few DLC missions .. like Arthur saves her from hanging and they go hide out, rob a few trains, banks and so on … maybe she could bust him out of jail .. dunno .. just really like her character together with him. That could go well with Arthur going to New Austin. Maybe he goes there to help her out. **hint hint Rockstar More stable space for more horses Being able to sell to the fence the extra guns you can pick up along the way. Let's face it, you only need so many weapons on your horse but to be able to pick up the guns after a shoot out and then take them to the fence to sell would be very cool. More treasure maps. I love hunting treasure. Figuring out where everything is etc. Calm the wolves down option rather than have to shoot them all the time … it could take a fair bit of patience and time but wish Arthur could get out of having to kill so many wolves. More gang challenges .. I really enjoy the challenges and activities with other gang members.. etc. Would love more of these. It gets lonely searching for treasure and legendary animals with no one for company. Can see Arthur taking on some of the hunts w/ Charles or even Lenny. Maybe teach Lenny how to hunt etc. More encounters with Charlotte. Arthur deserves a little romance. Not too sappy but .. I think he should be able to go see her more often. And more time w/ Hamish. Hamish was a hoot and a half. We lost him too soon. A few more friendlier camp sites - all the camp sites are so hostile. It would be fun to just ride up and join in some random conversations, stories etc. Get some clues for mysteries or treasure hunts etc. Add on towns and places … maybe secret ways to get through the mountains … and finally .. can we just beat the sh*t out of Micah at camp? I seriously dislike this man and want Arthur to be able to kick his ass in camp. He is such a bastard. The only character in the story that I want Arthur to actually shoot in the face (well, actually … there is that creepy rapist guy and the kid who is mean to his dog at Emerald Ranch, and the guy who punches his horse after losing the race, and the KKK racist idiots, but you get to shoot them down so there is some satisfaction in that ) and then one question for any one still reading this boring post .. how do you trigger the bust out of jail scenes for Arthur? I have never been arrested or even approached by bounty hunters unless running away from one of the scenes where you have robbed a train or bank etc. or a big shoot out scene. Does your honour have something to do with it because I normally have pretty high honour. I have been waiting for bounty hunters to catch up with him and take him to jail but doesn't happen. I have had Javier ride up random and you have to go rescue Bill but .. that's it. Any suggestions? Thanks for listening .. Cheers, UKRogueOne.

On PC, there is and option in the upper right of the Posse Directory that says "Start a Posse". Here's the link to do that: https://www.rdr2.org/forums/clubs/?do=create

Awesome, amazing...one of the games i especially bought my PS4 for. Nothing else to say, buy it and play it!

In a persistent posse you will probably have to remove some offline posse members in order to add the other players because posse members retain their position in persistent posses even when they are offline. I don’t know of any other work around at the moment.

Since taxpayers are the prime supporters of financial help for people, they should have more of a say when it comes to where their money goes. The problem is, like with everything else, a few bad eggs will spoil the bunch. Everything has to be set up to keep the small numbers from taking advantage of the larger numbers in all scenarios but there are still loopholes and it is being abused. The immigration condition in the US is one example of this. As far as I am aware of, everyone is not facing racism. Even whites. It has become more of a problem now then it was just 10 years ago. Everyone is turning everything into skin color, moral views, and lifestyle preferences. It is all just too damn tiresome. I am sick of seeing people who speak out against the wrongdoings of others and yet do the "wrong" themselves.

My brother had to go through a long and pointless custody battle when my nephew was a baby. He too applied for some sort of financial aid. When he went in for the interview, they literally told him "you're the wrong color" and sent him on his way. When I was looking for small scholarship opportunities through the local community college, I found that there is something for EVERYONE, excluding white males. There is such a thing as "white privilege", but we are also held to a different standard.

Fair enough, maybe so. If it's a big deal, I'm sure a moderator can move the thread to the right place.

Point taken. No need to make it anything more than it needs to be

If they get the medical system sorted out and make coming into the country easier and quicker, I don't think we would have nearly as many illegal immigrants. I am fine with immigrants, we have plenty of room and jobs despite what people think but there has to be a common understanding to abide by the laws of this country and to not take advantage of our government aid systems.

People are only against the wall because Trump is pushing for it. Obama, Bush, Hillary and Bill, they were all for putting a wall up but couldn't figure out the funding. The only reason the tide has shifted on it is that Trump wants it. I am not a fan of the man but people are acting really fn childish on both sides over it. I am talking specifically about the politicians not the identifying citizens in the general public. I expect MORE of the government. Not them acting like children.

Our border security works great. We just kick the sh*t out of any English that are dumb enough to come over.

Ron America became the behemoth it is today because substantively of the two world wars.... Wars which it stepped into at the most opportune moment for itself and it's currency. Whilst I see nothing wrong with that per se, that is the reality... It worked the wars to build the replacement for the tangible European empires it denounced at Versailles in 1919 and created a hegemonic fiscal power base, an intangible empire if you will.... That has not lasted.... Because capitalism turns and the USA along with the UK are now majorly 5th world countries, post industrial and wandering a wasteland of economic misery ..... Both were built on vast export power and control of other countries trade... But that has all withered and now they are left with the patriotic sentiment of power, but not the actual export/fiscal power. It is difficult to explain this highly complex subject, simply ..... For an economy to grow in a capitalist model, one must have immigration of poor people ... They in fact do not take jobs, they create work by their presence... They are willing to work longer and harder for less money than 'a local' because in their view, the money has more value. This creates new work....... It is somewhat strange that America, entirely built on immigration now wants a wall... well, the lower classes and less educated of course. There are many parallels to be drawn between the conditions both social and political of the US and the UK presently with European conditions of the 1920's ... The masses are swallowing the exact same propaganda for the self same reasons..... Economic demise, poverty and mostly fear of the unknown. Whilst businessmen say "Leave me alone so I may prosper' .... The working class/blue collar say "I must be given work" ... When there is no work to be had they look for someone or something to blame ... Immigrants are a very simple target but not the issue in any manner. But people like Trump and the Brexit mob, they pounce on this ignorance and they preach FEAR - GREED - HATE, just like the Fascists or National Socialists or Ultra Nationalists or indeed, Communists .... "Your life is awful because of those people... they are taking what is yours and laughing at you...." Then the masses work out the hate part on their own ... Now the clever part, because they fill in the hate, all of a sudden they think it was all their idea ... as Dr P Joseph Goebbels correctly identified "Propaganda works best when those who are being manipulated are confident they are acting on their own free will" Jobs did not leave the USA or UK because of cheap wages per se, they left because the wages of the masses in those countries were dropping in real terms...... In the UK for example, ordinary workers have not seen a rise in their real income since the early 1970's and I suspect the US is the same...... So to sell them goods, one has to make them cheaper... so one sends the work elsewhere ... Today in China they send much work to Myanmar, because China has become too expensive for many products to be made there for it's local economy. The capitalist wheel never stops turning. However it gets worse, much worse very soon ....... The real issue and the change from 20th century Europe is Ai and AGi ...... Ai, Artificial Intelligence and the more problematic, AGi .....Artificial General Intelligence. Ai means we program a robotic machine to do something and it follows those instructions to the letter ... Nothing more or less... If you tell it to paint the car pink, it paints the car pink until told to stop. Or pours coffee or flips burgers ........ Whilst AGI means a computer brain which says ... I think, therefore I am and it learns exponentionally by it;s own powers as a human child does.... but at billions of times the speed In tests so far the issues start when these AGi units talk to another, the fact there is another 'brain' tells them they are in existence, they have something to make comparison with. .... So quite soon while you might tell it paint cars pink, it might decide it prefers blue, or you have too many pink cars. The real upshot is this ... The turn of capitalism has created the loss of millions of manufacturing jobs in the USA & UK ... for them to be replaced by poorly paid service industry work .... But within 30 years there will be no service industry work either, because AGi and Ai will be doing it. Then one has to start to talk about a Universal Basic Income model, as is already happening in the halls of power ... Somehow people, the masses, they have to be sustained when there is simply no work for them...... We are returning to Rome and 'Bread and Circus', or maybe 'Rollerball' ...... But certainly free food and free entertainment. The fundamental issue with that, as my wife a Dr of Psychology will tell you, is the complete loss of hope. Who really buys lottery tickets? Plays bingo and other non-skilled gambling? Poorer people.... Whilst it is often millions and millions to one that they will win.... they still expend a relatively high % of their income on hope. That is what they are buying, hope. So when you have no job, no possibility of a job, when your life choices are very limited and almost totally dictated ... where is the hope? Just as these same people say 'I must be given work', then 'I must be given food and entertainment' they will soon say 'I must be given hope' It is a conundrum yet to be answered ... But the wall? That's just a smoke screen to stop the masses thinking.